MovieChat Forums > Harper's Island (2009) Discussion > BIGGEST plot hole in the entire thing

BIGGEST plot hole in the entire thing


why would you believe a sociopath if he told you he was your father and you were adopted?

reply

Too many to even mention, it's like each episode was was written by someone with no involvement in the show.

reply

Too many to even mention, it's like each episode was was written by someone with no involvement in the show.

reply

Too many to even mention, it's like each episode was was written by someone with no involvement in the show.

reply

I do agree that this was a bit ridiculous. I wish they had Abby say something like "how do you know he was telling you the truth" at some point.

reply