MovieChat Forums > The Debt (2011) Discussion > Aren't Mossad agents supposed to be Jewi...

Aren't Mossad agents supposed to be Jewish?


Am I nuts for finding it a bit confusing a redhead and two english looking dudes are playing bad ass mossad agents?? It also seems to take away from the scene (or entire film for that matter) where the evil nazi guy is trying to rile up one of the english looking blokes with his 'I was messing with your peoples' trash talk. They did the same crap with Munich too.

reply

What are Jews supposed to look like in your opinion? What does 'English looking' even means?




Will Graham: ‘I don’t find you that interesting.’
Hannibal Lecter: ‘You will.’

reply

I could see Oded Fehr instead of Sam Worthington since hes done a lot of action films, maybe Adam Goldberg. So many choices. I mean Eric Bana and James Bond as Jews in Munich?? What are they doing?

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Loved the exchange there between you two--good stuff. :-)
And thank you,guys for making me aware of some additional names of Jewish/half-Jewish/1/4 Jewish actors that I wasn't aware of(I pride myself on usually being on top of that kind of thing. ;-)

Apparently I need to go the jewornotjew website to brush up! (btw, if neither of you two are familar with said site, I recommend you check it out. Something tells me you two are the type of people just like myself that would get a kick out of it).

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Adam Goldberg has a mother of non-Jewish, English, Irish, German, etc. (German through the matrilineal line, btw), ancestry, so I would imagine he could look somewhat different from the full-blooded Jews you mentioned, yes.
------------------


He looks mostly like his dad but the point is you will not mistake this person for a German or English dude, confusing movie viewers. Plus he is pretty well known, established actor they could have used.

reply

wolfsskill I see what your doing there so why not mention Amar'e Stoudemire? Hes jewish too dontcha know, forget the redhead lets start casting 6-10 black men LOL

Nat portman...now we're talking bro. Should have casted her instead of ginger Jessica Chastain.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Daniel Craig is Jewish. Not sure about Bana.

reply

are you aware that Judaism is a RELIGION, not a nationality or race? do you understand what that even means? did you know that anyone can convert to any religion they choose? back to school with you.

reply

are you aware that Judaism is a RELIGION, not a nationality or race? do you understand what that even means? did you know that anyone can convert to any religion they choose? back to school with you.



It's also a national identity. Most of the self-identified Jews I've known were atheists. And that's the way the Nazi treated it. They weren't interested what religion the Jews practiced, they cared about their Jewish roots.

BBL

reply

It's called acting.

Chastain certainly can pass for Jewish, as can the other two younger actors. Sorry that the producers didn't pick actors who fit the stereotypes of what Jews must look like. But a lot of Jews don't fit the stereotype of what Jews look like.

reply

No Message

reply

I think the OP meant, should Mossad agents be Isreali's? People from a small middle eastern country who are generally dark haired, and olive skinned. However. Any jew can move to Isreal, and then be required to serve in the armed forces. If her mother died in Germany during the war, she probably wasn't born in Isreal, and can look however they cast the part.

reply

OP: I think you meant, "Aren't Mossad agents supposed to be Israeli?"


"Don't get chumpatized!" - The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters (2007)

reply