MovieChat Forums > 65 (2023) Discussion > Is there any science fiction screenwrite...

Is there any science fiction screenwriter who knows how BIG space is?


Space is empty. Solar systems are light-years apart. The likelihood that a ship would collide with an asteroid close enough to a planet that it can do an emergency landing is infinitesimal. Unless Earth was the destination, which doesn’t seem to be the case (and if it were, wouldn’t the freaking pilot be awake for the final approach?), it is extremely unlikely that the ship would be inside a solar system.

This is a very common mistake in science fiction movies and TV shows. There is always a planet nearby when you need one.

reply

The audience for this movie doesn't care.

reply

The research for this movie probably consisted of watching other movies... Or maybe a bit of Star Trek. I swear, when I first read about this one and saw the images posted, I thought - "Well, they land on an alien planet of dinosaurs and by the end of the film, two of them survive; a man and a woman." Cuz, that would be an original concept, right?

As of now, I don't care. It has dinosaurs and it looks like fun. I'll just assume it is stupid and hope that it is not that stupid.

reply

So instead of 6000 years it was 65 000 000 years?

reply

We are speaking here of what I like to call Rod Serling Sci-Fi. This may produce excellent drama (Mr. Serling certainly did) but it has no sense of scale in time or space (6000/6,000,000, it's just more 0s).

reply

You are going down a dangerous path... we're talking about someone from a different solar system who looks exactly human and also speaks English.

I was thinking they could have had him accidentally wander into an unknown wormhole that took him back in time. That solves some problems but creates others. At least the "velociraptors" were sized appropriately unlike in Jurassic Park

reply

They don't speak English, just like Ben-Hur and Spartacus didn't speak English in their respective movies.

I agree with you about their human looks though.

reply

According to the first draft of the movie, the Spartacus dialogue was supposed to be:



Spartacus: "Ich bien, Spartacus!"

Prisoner #2: "No! Ich bien, Spartacus!"

Prisoner #3: "Siiii, senor! Me llamo es Spartacus, tambien!"

Roman Guard: "To hell with this! Just kill the lot of em!"

reply

This is the classic case of knowing a Little about something, and allowing that to lead you down a hilariously irrelevant path.

I could go on at length, but the short version: it NEVER makes sense to complain about unlikely generative events that happen in novels, movies, plays, or any other narrative fiction.

Stop and think. No, really. STOP. Now Think About It: is it EVER reasonable to arch an eyebrow at a a story that proceeds from something really, Really, REALLY unlikely happening? (Hint: NO.)

It's the obverse of the absurdity coin, where people complain that something is Too Common/Familiar.

That is all.

reply

There are differences between things unlikely to happen and things that are impossible to happen.

reply

Uh huh. . .

reply

yes, Douglas Adams did

reply

Because it’s big - really, really big.

reply

dis hoopy frood gets it! ^ 👍

reply

Movie plot needs to happen and they had to bring him somehow on Earth.

reply

The real mistake they make is forgetting about relativity. If they can travel fast enough to get between star systems in a few years, they will be going so fast they will age much more slowly than the families they left behind. Not to mention that years that messages would take to get back and forth -- messages can't travel faster than light.

reply

The only thing I can think of is that from my general understanding, the galactic disk is 100 times wider than it is thick (100,000 light years across, 1000 thick).

It could just be that space travel is normally just done within the galactic disk for who knows what reason -- some means of travel efficiency to avoid the extra travel distance of traveling out of the disk to cross it, and then re-entering it? Some kind of navigation benefit? Some kind of resource or energy acquisition during the trip?

The thing I found strange about it was why the sensors and navigation system didn't detect the asteroid and debris field and just navigate around it. I would imagine that if your deep space vessels routinely pass through solar systems your odds of encountering uncharted rocks are relatively high.

reply