I kept mentally comparing this to The Matchmaker
I think Amy Adams was better than Janeane Garofalo.
However, the David Ohair was at least a belivable character. I never saw anything likeable in Mathew Goode.
The Matchmaker's local Irish characters were at also a cut above. Both movies even had stupid car accidents and the girl leaves her Irishman behind to find America empty without him.
Matchmaker was not a great movie, but I like it better than this one.