La Paloma (spoilers)


Fausta sang about a dove that had lost its soul because of paralyzing fear over what it had seen and experienced, and she exhorted the dove to conquer its fear and find its soul, find it in the earth. So I found it very compelling that, when the dog was sniffing at Fausta's potato plug and Fausta found a sick dove, she sacrificed the dove to the dog so that she could escape the dog's inquisitiveness.

At first I thought the dove in the song represented Fausta, and so when she sacrificed the real dove it seemed as if Fausta was saying that she, an ailing dove, was so deeply frightened she couldn't deal with her fears even to save her own life. But now I think the song dove represented Fausta's mother ("find it in the earth" referring to burial) and so the scene with the sacrificed dove seems to foreshadow Fausta finding the inner strength that will allow her to bury her mother, and their fears with her.

Any thoughts?

reply

wait...I do not want to be purist or activist or defendant of animal rights here...but...was it OK to use a real dove in this scene ? and show how it dies? and use caged doves? and use doves in the wedding festivities?? I know the director wants to portrait the culture, but was this really necessary?

reply

I don't have a problem with it. Everything dies and gets consumed anyway, either by us or by other animals or by plants that grow from its nutrients. So it doesn't bother me when that consumption takes the form of entertainment that nourishes my mind. It's all part of the beautiful complexity of the natural cycle of birth, death, and rebirth.

reply