Amy Adams killed it for me.
She's a remarkably unremarkable actress (admittedly, the only thing I liked her in was 'Catch Me If You Can', but that's only because she was playing a dimwitted teenage girl... actually, that's not true, I liked her in Julie and Julia).
She has this smug look on her face throughout the whole movie, and all I wanted her to do was stay away from precious childhood memories. I came to see The Muppets, not cringe at your acting and listen to you screech along to the music. At least Jason Segel is cute/funny, in an endearing kind of way.
She literally sucks the life out of her movies. 'The Fighter'. 'The Master'.
'Trouble With the Curve'. And now 'Man of Steel'. Fire-crotch!
Greatest Films Not in the IMDB Top 250http://www.imdb.com/list/bc9x1QAFat0/