The True Story


I've done tons of research on this story based on any and all information that I could find on the web, and it seems to me that this story was completely overblown. A lot of people are making some very rude and ill informed (not to mention hypocritical) comments towards these girls because the movie portrayed them as a bunch of vindictive, malicious and callous bitches. The reason this is a story isn't so much because of the what the girls allegedly did; it was the fact that they got away with it. The story here is that the adults did not take charge and failed to see discipline as a loving instruction in life. The adults failed to be adults. As for the girls, as allegedly bad as their behavior allegedly was, you really cannot and shouldn't place all the blame on their shoulders. They were being kids and having fun, and that's what high school is all about. The problem is that they were given no boundaries as to how far their fun could go. I highly doubt that all the shenanigans in the movie really occurred, especially the scene of them drinking on campus during school hours and them physically abusing other girls. I think the directors probably embellished and juiced it up to reinforce the stereotypical mean girls that they were trying to portray these girls as, because nowhere did I read or hear about these girls fighting with each other. The only antics that seem to be true in the real life scenario in comparison to the movie are the head cheerleader (Brooke/Karrissa) flipping off one of the coaches, talking on cell phones during class and telling the teacher to shut up once instructed to stop, and sending the dirty text message from the coach's cell phone. The infamous video of them in the movie isn't true either; it was pictures, not video, that were posted on MySpace of them in their uniforms. There are a lot of discrepancies in the movie compared to what really happened, based on my understanding with this story. I just find it really disheartening that so many strangers can talk badly about these girls and be so mean towards them while at the sake time only doing so because of how this movie portrayed them. I did, however, read somewhere that the real girls were given money by the producers of the film for their consent. I'm not sure if that's true, but if it is, then these girls really don't care about their reputations or images as a bunch of out of control, drunken, slutty bitches. Regardless, I don't think it's right for so many people to talk these girls down. Everybody says this kind of thing happens in every high school. It probably doesn't in every school but more than likely does in some schools, but that is not the kids' faults: it is the adults' faults. They are the ones who are in charge and responsible for enforcing rules. It's natural for teens to rebel against rules but it's up to the adults to stand their ground. The bigger picture is that nowadays we seem to have an epidemic of parents buddying up with their kids. They want to be a friend to their kids more than they want to be a parent, and this does their children a real disservice. I reckon some of this went on with the principal wanting to be her daughter's friend by allowing her and her friends to do whatever they wanted. The principal is whom everyone should be upset with because she abused her position by giving preferential treatment to one clique of students. In doing so, I will say that these girls learned a valuable lesson in life: that who you know (not how you act) can help you get ahead in life. Let me state that no I am not condoning these girls' behaviors; I am, however, saying that it's not entirely their fault. I'm sure they knew that what they were doing was wrong, but how were they supposed to know any different when no adults in charge told them to stop? I feel very sorry for these girls who are forever going to be haunted and harassed and ridiculed for what they did in high school. We all misbehaved, made stupid decisions and have many regrets from our teen years that, looking back upon now, we see in a different perspective. We learn from our mistakes so that we can become better people, and I'm sure these girls have learned their lesson and are just wanting to move on with their lives. That's what growing up is all about. I urge all of us who are calling these girls every ugly name in the book to stop and instead point our fingers of shame to the adults. It was, after all, their fault why this happened.

reply

They were being kids and having fun, and that's what high school is all about.


High School is not about having fun. High School is about getting an education.

reply

"High School is not about having fun. High School is about getting an education."

Exactly. Thank you.

"Issues of control happen when we're tired!"

reply

I think your post here is longer than the movie. Not so many words next time.

reply

Do you think the real girls will be haunted? To be haunted they would need to accept that what they did was wrong. Yes this is a tv movie. So I know the whole story is not told. But assigning blame to parents when teenagers know right and wrong is only assigning half the blame, in my opinion. Many kids make the right decisions at a very early age, with less parental support. When we make a decision to only benefit ourselves, we don't care about anyone else. I'm not saying become Mother Theresa, but the rights of an individual are the same. Some forget that.

As for the girls accepting money, they must have good self esteem to know that what is portrayed is either them or its not them, no one put gun to their heads to take the money.

If we can save humanity, we become the caretakers of the world

reply

What's this about them accepting money? What would this money be for, and where's it coming from? Anyway I think the principal was to blame more than anyone else, don't you?

Long live the 80's!

reply

The OP mentioned or I read on this board that the original girls were paid so prevent any issues with this film of their lives. Some of the story maybe true or parts left out. If girls agreed to this story, no lawsuits to prevent it from airing, they are okay with this version, because it's either true or it's not.
As for blame, I disagree. The mom doesn't seem to be a parent, no boundaries established. But that's with all the girls, no boundaries. But at some point, we are know right from wrong. You can blame others for just so long. These girls seemed to be victims of their home lives (no discipline) and villains to peers. If they were following orders from their parents, then yes. But these girls were plotting on their own, so I disagree that it's the principle's fault. She was being lied to by all the girls.

If we can save humanity, we become the caretakers of the world

reply

Which one of these girls are you? I have no sympathy for snotty spoiled girls who get away with bad behavior. But then again, I'm a mature adult.

reply