MovieChat Forums > The Boys (2019) Discussion > S1: The whole anti-Christian thing is no...

S1: The whole anti-Christian thing is not brave, Hollywood...


They think they are so brave bashing Christians in their movies and tv shows. Yawn...try bashing Islam instead and let's see if you are really brave. Now THAT would be a bold move but they won't do it of course because the left fears Islam and even goes out of it's way to protect it even tho it's ideals are diametrically opposed to everything the left claims to uphold.

reply

But it's Christianity that is having a grasp on America, not Islam.
I don't think they think it's bold either, but what the actual motivation is I don't know.

reply

America has been getting destroyed by secularism for decades now. Christianity has nothing to do with it.

reply

Secularism is a must in a modern society...or are not you for freedom of religion?
I mean that as a separation of church and state...privately you can believe whatever you're convinced of.

reply

The only problem is the founding fathers didn't have the foresight to define what religions were in some bold terms. Simply stating religion referred to Judaeo-Christian ones would have been sufficient. Given Thomas Jefferson fought the muslims and knew their cult of hatred was never going to work with Christianity. It would also eliminate the wacko things like Scientology and Pastafarians.

reply

What the eff are pastafarians doing that is so wacko?

reply

If you have to ask you would never understand.

reply

Oh sure, you’re so misunderstood.

reply

So what do u believe in that you’re convinced of... capitalism, marxism, left ideology, right ideology, liberism, nazism?... which “ism” u believe in?

reply

Politically I'm left on some questions and right on others. I'd say center with a lean to the left. Not the BLM/Feminist/HBTQ/triggered left though.
Religiously I'm not convinced of a god, making me an Atheist.
Economically I think capitalism is our best current option, but it needs to be regulated so the wealth is more evenly distributed.

reply

Well said.

reply

" I'm not convinced of a god" Why is that not agnostic? Are you saying you have doubt as to existenceither way or do you mean "convinced there is not a god"?

Just curious. No issue. thanks

reply

Everyone who is intellectually honest admit they are an "agnostic atheist" or "agnostic theist" since no one actually knows, and probably could not know, I just don't bother...if you believe in god you're a theist, if not, an atheist, simple.
I'm a firm atheist so I could very well say "convinced there is not a god".

reply

Thanks for the clarification.

reply

I’m an agnostic dyslexic, I’m not convinced my dog is real.

reply

I can live with that!

reply

Agreed. Religious Nationalism is the kind of crap you see in countries like Iran, yet we have self labeled Christians like Falwell and the Christian Right demanding legal precedent for their religious doctrine.

reply


Secularism can only improve a society, not destroy it.

Religion is the most repugnant of human inventions.



reply

One could argue that religion has a unifying function as it gives the same sense of direction and purpose to its followers which is very good to keep a certain level of harmony inside its community (and sometimes a whole society).

A second person could argue that it's nothing less than brainwashing used to control the people so the ones on top can use them as they please to gain money, power, and thus fulfill their own agendas.

Both have their flaws but both seem more peaceful than this in-between chaotic and uncertain phase we seem to be in right now.

reply

Secularism can only improve a society if the religions with the society are peaceful... but when you have one like Islam that promotes conversion or elimination of the non-believers then you have a problem that secularism can't deal with. In that instance you need a strong dictator to keep the violent muslims in their place. Look at Iraq, it was only peaceful when you had Saddam ruling with an iron fist otherwise violence out the ass rules that country.

reply

It is also more dangerous and destructive than any virus or disease.
It is also more dangerous and destructive than any man-made weapon.

reply

Agreed. Secularism is the result of people thinking for themselves and creating their own destiny. Religion is a system of control that tells everyone they have to buy into it if they want to be saved.

reply

I used to think the same thing. (And I am an atheist BTW.) However... People seem to have a very deep-seated need to believe in some kind of greater power, cause, or movement, and when religion fades away, most of them seem to replace it with an ideology of some sort. And then they can become every bit as fanatically devoted to that ideology as any holy inquisitor ever was to the Roman Catholic Church. Friedrich Nietzsche anticipated the war of competing ideologies that would take place in society when traditional religion faded away, and he was right, as the bloody history of the 20th century illustrates.

If we could get rid of religion and be very rational beings I would completely agree about the desirability of eliminating religion. Sadly, as the late scifi author Robert A. Heinlein pointed out man is not a rational animal, he is a rationalizing one. And all too often people devote their mental energy not to seek facts and truth, but to justify conclusions they've already reached for largely emotional reasons. In that sort of setup, religion can actually be a stabilizing factor in society, and serve a useful function.

reply

Christianity is a plague? LOL Go to a Muslim nation and say anything bad about Islam and see how long you survive. Whereas people bash Christians all the time here and nothing happens. That's the difference. Liberals are scared of Muslims in two ways. Because they want their votes in our elections. And because they know Muslims will literally murder over their silly religion.

reply

Just because Islam is worse it doesn't mean Christianity is good.
America still suffers from home schooled young-earth creationist retards that wants influence..indoctrinating kids generation after generation, spreading ignorance.
It's below a modern nation to believe in fables, and superstition is of no help for anyone.
As I said, the show takes place in America, it's natural that they focus on the local religion if they want to criticize it.
And muslims are indeed more sensitive about their stories, Christians can take it..so rather than a lack of balls it might be to avoid disrespecting the more delicate group.

reply

At this point, I'd rather they be indoctrinated into Christianity than liberal nonsense.

reply

Unless you're an atheist, you don't get to call any religion "silly" since they're all a bunch of nonsense.

reply

I think it's fair to say that some are sillier than others.

reply

Well of course a member of one religion is going to think that theirs is less silly than others.

reply

Wait, do you think all religions are equally silly?

reply

Yeah, but at least most religions aren't violent, unlike Islam.

reply

Don't you think it's fair to class extreme violence with the justification of religion as silly? Hence, it's demonstrable that some religions are sillier than others.

reply

I'm talking mainly about the superstitious aspects of religions really, e.g the theories about creationism, how the universe began and whatnot.

reply

Faugh! You've obviously never researched the Neo Christian Contemporary Episcopalian Methodistic Church of Western Monkey's Eyebrow, Kentucky. The one and only true religion.

reply

Instead of "plague" I would have said "having a grasp on" but yeah. The difference is their influence. I'm surprised that Arianna Grande's number one fan didn't get that.

reply

That is a better wording...plaguing is a bit harsher than I intended. Changing it.

reply

👍

reply

What are you talking about. Islam was the boogeyman in movies and tv for like 10 years after 2001. Same with Russia being the boogeyman during the Cold War.

reply

Exactly. True Lies, Executive Decision, Iron Man, Taken, even as far back as Raiders of the Lost Ark which had Muslim characters who readily aligned themselves with the Nazis.
Hollywood was never afraid of Islam.

reply

Well, Hitler liked the muslims for their views on zee jews...

reply

He also came to power because a majority of Germans accepted the trope of hating and blaming zee jews for all of their sufferings. The Nazis also used this belief system to get other conquered Eastern Europeans to rat out and hunt down Jews in their countries.

reply

Christians LOVE to be persecuted. We live in a predominantly Christian Culture, it’s relevant.

reply

Are they (the "they" in this show) bashing Christians though? Or are they bashing hypocrites who pretend to be devout for corporate and personal gain?

You can't tell me that a corporation's biggest base in the US won't be Christian, and that it won't take advantage and pander to that audience to make money. Do you think Ezekiel is a true Christian? I don't.

There is bashing going on here, but it isn't Christian bashing, it's bashing of corporations who commodify faith.

As for the Muslims, you can have your opinions about them and Islam, but they haven't allowed for their faith to be turned into a commercial product. Even if Islam wasn't largely irrelevant for a critique of American society, that alone would make it unsuitable for what they're doing here.

reply

Just when I was about to crawl back into bed and pull the covers over my head, there's a reasoned, balanced reply to the torrent of stupidity on this thread.

Thanks.

reply

It feels nice to be appreciated :)

reply

the so-called Christians in this series weren't really Christians but hypocrites.

reply