Black Dynamite vs Undercover Brother

I was JUST about to post the exact same discussion!

I really think it depends on what your preferences are for comedy. They both do the same thing (parody blacksploitation movies) in completely different ways, and they both did it very well.

I liked Undercover Brother a little more, because it was more "clever" and "good-natured". Parts of Black Dynamite had me in stitches, but overall it relied more on shock and "dick joke" humor to get the job done, which can get old really fast for me. Not to mention that BD essentially took the same plot as UB (The Man poisoning a stereotypically "black people" consumable to loosen the black populace's hold on America/the world).

I actually think that the differences in the main plot point are perfect for showcasing the differences between the two different approaches:

-Undercover Brother has the poison used for mind control, causing prominent black figures (with the hope of eventually all black people) to become more prone to "white" behavior (i.e. behavior the white establishment can be comfortable with).

-Black Dynamite has the poison shrink black males' dicks, causing them to lose the will to live.

I also liked the characters in UB more, as well as its portrayal of "The Man".

Black Dynamite is funny, while Undercover Brother is fun.

That's a hard one, I just saw BD today and thought it was hilarious. In terms of blaxplotation I think BD did a better job.

________________________________________
What happened happened and can't happen any other way

Black Dynamite is far superior, although I had a blast with Undercover Brother too.

[deleted]

Undercover Brother for damn sure... But Pootie Tang beats em both

A wrong decision is better than indecision

Undercover Brother is a good comedy but Black Dynamite is one of my all time favorites.

I like what was written above about them having similar plots, but very different approaches, yet many of the 70's films did pointlessly go into conspiracy theories so it fits.

My impressions of Undercover Brother is its very much in line with the first couple Austin Powers movies. A light broad and good natured style that takes in a great many elements from the period but is clearly a product of its own time and place. Dave Chappelle and Neal Patrick Harris to a large extent steal the show.

The thing that gets to me about Black Dynamite is that it never quite drops the disguise and really goes out to recreate the 70's exploitation movies, and most of the jokes are meta-humor. The incredibly obvious dialogue, and the score that verges on narration parody how many movies seem to think the audience can't follow the plot and they keep on that theme. There's the Big Lipped Alligator moment of the pointless sequence on Kung Fu Island where it becomes a Vietnam movies for a few minutes. But what is present the whole time is the entire film is something of a movie within a movie as the actors are not playing their characters, but rather particular actors from the period playing those characters. Watch for the guy who keeps messing up and reading his stage directions, or the people with the wrong accents, or Black Dynamite (or should I say Ferante Jones) in his habit of going blank after he says his lines.

Something that comes across really well in Black Dynamite is a 70's trope of the hero being actually pretty sadistic often pointlessly so.

There are surface tropes that are popular to make fun of, like really bad stunt doubles, especially for 70's exploitation films to the point that some mainstream works will take a moment to parody them (like the capture of the stunt doubles in Spaceballs). The thing that helps Black Dynamite hold up to repeated viewings is that they really studied those films, and others, to pick out the tropes that were not already routinely made fun of.

Black Dynamite all the way, Undercover Brother was about a guy stuck in the 70's in a modern world...Black Dynamite was a parody of Blaxpoitation, but also had many easter eggs and hidden things you only notice with repeat watching.

Wayne Enterprises buys and sells companies like Stark Industries

Black Dynamite by far. Didn't care for Undercover Brother that much.