MovieChat Forums > 3 Idiots (2009) Discussion > Why do people hate this movie?

Why do people hate this movie?


It's one of the best movies in years, and it's a movie that I can watch over and over and still be entertained and inspired. C'mon Westerners, is an 8.4 really that high? Clean out your own mess of a Top 250 board before you judge our films. I take 3 Idiots, Taare Zameen Par, Lagaan, and Gangs of Wasseypur over a lot of the films on that list.

reply

[deleted]

I enjoy it as well, but it takes away from the films. 3 Idiots is great, regardless of what White Devils think.

reply

I really enjoyed it.. I loved how they really did get such a range of emotions within one film and I really do love the bromance aspect but I'm not sure whether I would call it one of the best films ever. I would compare it more with The Hangover

reply

It's not a bad movie, but I don't think that it's better than any other classic teen comedy out there. Some jokes are lifted from somewhere else, the lenght is too much (I have the same problem with any movie that runs longer than 120 minutes), the themes are spread in a way that don't impact me as much as they could... I had a lot of problems with it. It has some good jokes, but that won't put it in a top list for me.

reply

"C'mon Westerners, is an 8.4 really that high?"

I am an Indian and actually, it's quite high.

" Clean out your own mess of a Top 250 board before you judge our films."

That I can surely agree with.

reply

I'm a "white devil" and I love this movie!

reply