MovieChat Forums > Ninja Assassin (2009) Discussion > Most blood ever in a non-horror movie?

Most blood ever in a non-horror movie?


I think I am right on this. Nobody will really remember the story or action scenes, Just the turnoff of too much blood.

Q.T.'s Kill Bill had lots of blood, but that was one scene for comical effect.





reply

I think I am right on this. Nobody will really remember the story or action scenes, Just the turnoff of too much blood.

I think you might be right for the most blood in a non horror movie. As far as no one remembering the story or action, you might be wrong on that one. I would say Raizo has made quite an impression on females and or males those who swing that way. This movie has 46 fan fiction stories and more on the way.

The interracial relationship between Mika and Razio is what will keep this movie alive oh and Rain's body.







If I wanted to kill my husband,I'd do it and I wouldn't get caught.I'd scare him to death.

reply

People will remember the superb action of this movie. It's a breath of fresh air as opposed to the same old gun fights and fist fights...

reply

People will remember ... this movie.


Hahaha. Look how dead this board is already, for a supposed "blockbuster" from just 3 years ago.

Even this small thread from 2 years ago was still on page 1.

reply

This is the goriest non-horror movie ever made and i have watched many horror movies that makes "Braindead" look like a kids movie.

reply

LOL! Yeah, this is quite a bloody movie, but I still remember the action and I really enjoyed this movie. I wasn't expecting ninjas fighting to be neat & clean.

reply

Definitly not the most gory non-horror I've seen, it is very gory and the severed limbs look good, but the blood is obviously digital. It rates pretty highly though, especially for a modern American film.

Off the top of my head try; The Story of Ricky, The Lone Wolf and Cub series, some of Takashi Miike's films, the trashy B-Movie Japanese stuff like Tokyo Gore Police and Machine Girl (although these are cheap and silly), even the recent Machete was on par, maybe worse.

I'd actually say Kill Bill is more violent, because you can see everything a lot more clearly. Thought the action was better too.

reply

[deleted]

Pretty sure tokyo gore police and those kinds of movies fall into the horror genre (wierd monsters, cruel villians, tons of gore = horror)


I'd describe TGP as a sci-fi/action film, all the weirder elements are hardly unusual in a sci-fi film. As two of the three criteria could also apply to Ninja Assassin, it becomes a bit self-defeating and/or circular. You'd end up having to come up with so many caveats it'd make the discussion pointless - "is this the most blood used in an action film with non-horror elements (as decided by some kind of committee)?" Also, as has been pointed out, the New Japanese Gore films take their blood-letting inspiration from older films, especially the more exploitationy chanbara films of the 70s, so if you want to find similar purely action films with large amounts of bloodshed you could look there. However, some of the NJG films also have little or no horror elements - "Hard Revenge Milly" and "Hard Revenge Milly: Bloody Battle" would count and there is plenty of blood shed (as the name would imply), special make-up effects were also by Yoshihiro Nishimura, the director and special effects guy behind TGP.

You have two main problems with assessing the amount of blood sloshed around in Ninja Assassin:

* Each cut doesn't release a lot of blood, compared to the high pressure fountains popular in Japanese films (going back to an accident on the set while filming Sanjuro), so you have to rely on there being a lot of deaths and, while I've not counted them, I suspect some of the Lone Wolf and Cub films have a similar body count but also employ fountaining blood. Hell they even took on ninjas and I'd be surprised if that scene wasn't on the minds of those behind Ninja Assassin: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUe7GemjjdA (although NA is more a homage to the ninja films of the 80s, so....).

* The bulk of the blood seen on screen is CGI, which makes it impossible to assess the amount of it there is - with Braindead, all you need do is find out how much fake blood they had and what was left over. As Tokyo Gore Police uses a lot of old school special effects, you could get a reasonable assessment of the volume of claret spilled there.

James McTeigue discusses the extensive use of stylised, CGI blood here: http://www.filmschoolrejects.com/features/exclusive-james-mcteigue-tal ks-ninja-assasin-interview-colea.php

reply

Yeah. I wouldn't count TGP in horror, I only really include a film in the genre if it's aiming to scare me. It's got Horror elements though sure.

www.projectphotodoodle.blogspot.com

reply

I'm a bit of a purist when it comes to film blood and cgi blood just doesn't do it for me at all. It comes off as violent as some digitally included snowflakes, just because it's red, doesn't mean it's impressive. If you count Ninja Assassin as a gory movie then you'll have to include videogames into the equation as well.

Film blood: no mess, no fun.

reply

[deleted]

CGI blood doesn't count. Kill Bill is way bloodier, and much more impressive. Shogun Assassin is up there, too.

Low budget film director, with punk rock sensibilities.

reply

CGI blood doesn't count.

Totally agree.

CG GORE IS THE WORST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO THE HORROR GENRE!

reply

Isn't it just weird to insist on real fake blood?

But seriously, the craft that goes into traditional effects and the fact that you have actual physical objects in front of the camera is so essential to movies with gore, it cannot be understated.

reply