MovieChat Forums > Dostana (2008) Discussion > a scene copied from '13 going on 30'

a scene copied from '13 going on 30'


the scene where priyanka is asked to 'redesign' the magazine.
and the whole photo shoot which john does for her - including the fall leaves and all the fun they are having together is lifted from jennifer garner's movie '13 going on 30'. i wonder if this is plagiarism too

reply

Plagiarism is legal in India. If studios/movies start suing bollywood for copying stuff, more than half the industry will go out of business.

reply

good get rid of the *beep* and actually think about quality over quantity for once. seriously the ripoffs are just plain annoying now.

reply

''Plagiarism is legal in India. If studios/movies start suing bollywood for copying stuff, more than half the industry will go out of business.''

---------------------------------------------------------------------

So you are saying that if we start putting gansters in jail their families will suffer so let them terrorise us. Very interesting philosophy of yours. LOL !!!

''Just because you've got the emotional range of a teaspoon doesn't mean we all have''

reply

Yeah!
I noticed that too, and just as I messaged my friend about it, he replies back, 'Its a rip off of I now pronounce you Chuck and Larry!'

So basically, I paid 300 Rs and got to see 3 movies in 1! Now, thats Value for money ;)

reply

"So basically, I paid 300 Rs and got to see 3 movies in 1! Now, thats Value for money ;) "

AHahah! Paisa vasool indeed! (although let me repeat that Dostana is not a copy at all of Chuck and Larry, which is itself 'inspired' from another movie).
I once saw a snippet of a documentary about plagiarism in Bwood, and they were saying that hindi audiences don't want to see English movies, they want to see those same movies adapted to their culture, language and mannerisms.

reply

but bollywood films art not only adapting the stories from hollywood, but they are also adopting their language, mannerisms, and culture

reply

thats true. bollywood is adopting the culture from hollywood as well.
like what kind of girl based on indian culture would get in lingerie and watch horror movies with her two gay roommates? (ever noticed that scene-i guess it was part of a song)...

reply

i noticed this to.

reply

Good point. John Abraham's character also happens to be a photographer who helps with the "redesign photo shoot" much like Jennifer Garner's love interest (Mark Ruffalo) in "13 Going on 30". I also noticed a brief pilfering of the chest-waxing scene from "The 40-year old Virgin". (They even had Asian women doing the waxing like the Hollywood movie!)...

... and of course, Abhishek's male-nurse angle taken from "Meet the Parents" (a movie that Bollywood seems to love borrowing liberally from). "Chuck and Larry" has been mentioned before, but the whole idea of pretending to be gay to score a convenient living situation was done with much popularity in the 70s ("Three's Company").

"Dostana" is like a cinematic smoothie blended from many different movies.

reply