MovieChat Forums > Dostana (2008) Discussion > Priyanka chose Bobby Deol over John Abra...

Priyanka chose Bobby Deol over John Abraham? BULLSH*T!


Title says all. How unrealistic.

reply

I know I wouldn't have! The other guy was great for her, too! I just don't see it working between her and her boss, plus his lil guy!

reply

You know, there are beautiful women who are not shallow and golddiggers.

There's ALWAYS money in the banana stand!

reply

she thought he was gay this whole time. It would be super shallow to suddenly change her mind when its revealed he's straight.

reply

Why would anyone choose somebody who not only lies to you over and over and over again...but psycholically abuses five year-old children???

reply

lol, that's what I kind of liked about this movie. Usually in Indian movies, the so called 'hero' is always super innocent and noble and has like no flaws. Here the two protagonists did some pretty *beep* up *beep* And in the end, they did their best to redeem themselves. I really do think movies like this are a good step in the right direction. Is it a great movie, maybe to some, but I don't think so. It is enjoyable though and the characters are, in a way, relatable.

reply

"Why would anyone choose somebody who not only lies to you over and over and over again...but psycholically abuses five year-old children???"

Great answer!

Also, the story would have been sort of sad if she had chosen either of her "gay" friends. Their friendship would have been shattered: one would have been left out and the other one would have "won" leaving the "loser" feeling bitter and probably jealous. This way they can still be friends, both the guys with each other and them with Priyanka. The film is called Dostana after all.

reply

Simple answer? Neha and Kunal were friends. She was in love with Ahbi. Remember: early in the movie Neha acknowledged her roommates being "two hot guys" but she never seemed to entertain any feelings other than friendship for either guy.

reply