Emma
If she was a virgin wouldn't it be more painful than what was shown.
shareWell they didn't show the moment she first lost it with Peter. So who knows...she could have been hurt and bled at that time.
shareLosing virginity is NOT necessarily painful in most situations, for girls and guys alike! Those who have masturbated before (girls, especially should feel no pain at all. People can totally enjoy their first time and climax. I personally think Emma enjoyed her 'time' with Caleb because she clearly desired him and was secretly attracted to him, just like he was with her.
share