MovieChat Forums > The Girl on the TrainĀ (2009) Discussion > 'Girl' brings true scandal to finely det...

'Girl' brings true scandal to finely detailed life

This is a review by Reuters for anyone who is interested to know more about this movie.

"Girl" brings true scandal to finely detailed life
Fri Mar 27, 2009
By Bernard Besserglik

PARIS (Hollywood Reporter) - Andre Techine's many admirers will not be disappointed by his latest offering, "The Girl on the Train," but they might be hard-pressed to define it.

Ostensibly the movie is, in the words of one of the main characters, "the story of a lie," but as always with this director, the pleasures reside in the fine detail rather than the broad sweep. Art-house audiences will be well rewarded. The film, which opened March 18 in France, plays in April at the annual City of Lights, City of Angels French film festival in Los Angeles.

Techine's starting point is a true story that raised a storm in France five years ago when a young woman announced that she had been the victim of an anti-Semitic attack on a Paris suburban train, creating a media uproar that drew in even the head of state, only for the affair to be revealed as a fabrication.

If the material is at first sight unpromising, a first-rate cast brings it to life: Emilie Dequenne as the girl, here named Jeanne; Catherine Deneuve as her workaday mother, Louise; and Michel Blanc as the successful lawyer Bleistein, a former flame of Louise's with whom Jeanne seeks employment.

The movie is divided into two halves, entitled "Circumstances" and "Consequences," but it's anything but schematic. The first half deals mainly with a burgeoning love affair between Jeanne and Franck (Nicolas Duvauchelle), a would-be professional wrestler, while in the second we are drawn more into Bleistein's world and that of his son Alex (Mathieu Demy) and fearsome daughter-in-law Judith (Ronit Elkabetz).

Techine makes no attempt to analyze Jeanne's motives or draw conclusions from her action on the state of French youth today, the volatile nature of the media or the current threat or otherwise of anti-Semitism in France. He is interested in the secondary relationships as much as the plot points: Louise's hesitant renewal of relations with Bleistein (both have been widowed), Judith's estrangement from Alex, a bond formed between Jeanne and the couple's 13-year-old son.

This makes for a relative dispersion of the points of interest, but the movie is held together not simply by Dequenne's fine portrayal of a young woman searching for herself and drawing a blank but by the force of Techine's attachment to his characters, the fluidity of his style and his characteristic blend of lightness and gravity. The presence of Techine regulars Deneuve and Blanc (and Alain Sarde, for the score) lend a sense of continuity with the director's previous work, with no sign of a lowering of standards.

Are you saying that real life isn't like in the movies?!


Thanks, obscure. This is a good link, indeed. I am going to see this film, very soon. I have "a thing" for French films set in the modern day, about French people, their cultures, and lives.
And, I don't know all that much about the event upon which this film is based either. Am hoping to learn a bit more ...

-- I admire celebrities who muck in & get dirt under their manicures. Charity rules!