MovieChat Forums > You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger (2010) Discussion > I wish things ended better for Naomi Wat...

I wish things ended better for Naomi Watts's character


I mean, yes, she was awfully disrespectful to her mother (although let's face it, it's not like she was wrong), but she didn't deserve for every single aspect of her life to be such a shambles.


reply

What exactly did she do to deserve anything better?

She is a terrible wife who has the nerve to get angry at her husband for not being able to have an affair, as well as being angry at him for not wanting to have a child when they are having serious relationship problems. She throws herself at her boss, even after she finds out that he's happily involved with her good friend. Then she yells at her mother for refusing to finance an extremely risky business venture after she quits her job, simply because she's resentful that her boss doesn't want her. Her character had no redeeming qualities at all.

-
You did just fine, Clarence. Now go git yo'self some hot cornbread!

reply

What redeeming qualities did her husband have? How on earth does he "deserve" a hot young gf?


reply

Oh, I agree. Her husband was just as bad. Neither of them deserved a happy ending. But just because her husband was a tool doesn't change the fact that she was a total b-tch and completely unlikeable as well.

-
You did just fine, Clarence. Now go git yo'self some hot cornbread!

reply

Neither of them deserved a happy ending.
I agree and not too many of the characters actually end up with a happy ending in this film, which says something about the way they were drawn and perhaps what Woody Allen wanted to say about placing your trust in illusions and false hope.🐭

reply

The husband's going to get his, but just a little later. The friend will wake up and out him for being a thief. No money, no fame, no job, no girlfriend, no place to live.

reply

Karma? What goes around comes around? But she wasn't any worse than the other characters, except her husband maybe, and they ended up without their lives in shambles.

reply

I had a lot of sympathy for Sally. She was simply the victim of bad luck, in that her mother, whom she had supported through hard times, had become a delusional lunatic, and her friend snatched a wonderful romantic opportunity away from her.

I think her failings were in supporting her husband when it was clearly unrealistic to expect his writing would ever be viable, and also her poor judgement in allowing her mother to be taken in by the fake psychic, when she needed her for financial support.

reply

I had sympathy for Sally too, she wasn't a bitch like some posts stated, she just had bad luck and bad marriage and that brought the worst out of her. She wasn't intended to be a bad person. She was an errant, nice person.

But, this:

her friend snatched a wonderful romantic opportunity away from her.

is just isn't true. It was pretty clear from their awkward conversation that Banderas' character wasn't attracted to Sally. There was no wonderful romantic opportunity... just Sally thought there was.

reply

[deleted]

You still insist... she had no chance, Banderas didn't want her at all. It was a humiliating moment for Sally. This was the scene all about; how bad her things turned despite her efforts to make his life better.

reply

[deleted]

I don't think it's a matter of viewpoint. The screenwriter (in this case, Allen) wanted to tell us that she misinterpreted her boss' behavior.

reply

I agree. Banderas didn't want her and had insinuated it how many different ways! He said they were colleagues and now competitors, and friends. No romantic interest there. I felt bad for her. So awkward!

reply

Yeah, I agree, first because she's Naomi Watts and secondly, because her husband was a nice piece of a total a**hole

nothing brainy to say here

reply

why did she deserve financial support from her mother?

isn't she old enough to support herself?

reply