Ending plot hole (spoilers)
Whenever the Reverend steals a soul, the body of the victim would have their eyes melt out of their eye sockets like vanilla pudding. And from the looks of Charlie's body; they would shrivel up "Imhotep style" like in the movie "The Mummy".
How come the little girl's eyes didn't explode out of her face like all of the other victims? She didn't even shrivel up into a prune like 100% of the other victims.