MovieChat Forums > The Watch (2008) Discussion > What were they thinking? *spoilers*

What were they thinking? *spoilers*


The part I found hard to believe was other students terrorizing her for a psychology thesis. What were they thinking, they never would have got away with this, even if they had her signature of consent.

First of all, if she had consented, she would know it was an experiment, so the analysis had to be different, you cannot study someone's behaviour in a known test situation as if it was an unknown situation without messing the whole thing up. And they surely couldn't write something like "we just tricked her to sign it without reading it, so she didn't know"!

But even if she had known it was an experiment, they wouldn't be able to use this, because universities, especially psychology departments, have a code of ETHICS and an ethics board to watch over them, and thus would never allow any experiment that could do somebody major harm. The times when psychology could do just anything in experiments are long gone. I know because my brother graduated in psychology and they were not even allowed to test how people would react to a drunk nun in a bar, because it could hurt somebody's religious feelings. It was not even a conservative university, he told me experiments would not be allowed if they could just bring any medium discomfort to anyone.

So putting a former abduction victim in a lone and dark forest hut to scare the sh!t out of her? Don't make me laugh!

reply

The ending was disappointing, no doubt about it. Why couldn't it be a ghost story in stead?

reply

Meh, the movie was playing on the common misconception that getting people to sign a contract somehow magically makes anything legal. Of course, the rest of us knows better; informed consent is required and, even then, that still may not mean it's allowed.

Little Albert experiment, anyone?

The ending just wasn't very good. I was hoping for something more.

---
Pleased to meet you.

reply

What bothered me is that she didn't report them!! I'm sure people do unethical stuff all the time, but they should have been punished for it.

If it were me, I would have reported them to the university and had them booted out of their program in disgrace. Stealing her counselling file alone is grounds for dismissal, never mind the other stuff they tried to pull. And that's probably close to $75K in tuition fees (depending where they go to school, more like $40,000 if it's a Canadian university, school's cheaper here, although post-grad is more expensive than undergrad).

And I absolutely didn't buy her dating the guy at the end, that was beyond belief. I mean, I don't care how cute someone is, you can't forgive that kind of behaviour!

reply

I wonder what YOU were thinking. Come on...it's only just a movie. It's not real. The more you think and worry about all the technical stuff, the less likely you will enjoy the whole movie-watching experience.

reply

[deleted]