MovieChat Forums > Bimong (2008) Discussion > This is clearly one of his worst movies

This is clearly one of his worst movies


Kim Ki-duk is not a bad director. He makes great movies, like Time, Bin-jip, or Bad Guy, or The Samaritan girl, or Spring etc..., or even The Bow. These are well done movies, and the only reason I didn't mention the Isle here, is because I'm not a big fan of torturing animals, but otherwise: well done! What do these movies have what Bi-mong doesn't?

They have a message. Not always a very clear one, not always a very strong one, but they're about something. This film has a lot of bad symbolism (like the white and the black dresses) a lot of unneccessary violent acts (like the man, torturing himself to stay awake) and of course the director's favorit: the tragic suicide, with beautiful images after, but no message at all (and the assumption, that everything is a dream, and it's hard to find love is not a message, it's an assumption.) Maybe he should make less films, and sleep before them himself.

reply

he lost it somewhere in the middle and make a child's play till the end that's how i see it.... such a waste it could have been better... : C

Les Noir

reply

I don't get why this is considered one of his weaker films, I personally love it. I think it has all the good things we love and appreciate in other Kim Ki-Duk films Strong leads, poetic ending, "weird" romances.. It's just very enjoyable for me anyway..

Mavis, I'm a married man!

reply