For Writers, By Writers


I think this movie is for creative writing people, which is perhaps too narrow an audience for this to ever have succeeded. It's just not terribly compelling to people who haven't gone to writing workshops or tried to be published or dealt with issues like plagiarizing, or seen with how bizarre professional writers can become.
It SHOULD be funny to anyone, but it's just not for some reason I've struggled to understand. All I can come up with is, they're just not like me. And that's okay. But it sucks this was such a commercial failure when it succeeds at what it tries to be.

reply

I don't think it's necessarily written for writers.

The thing the masses miss is the subtlety of it. Perhaps writers have a keener receptiveness to subtle humor and character quirks, but I have a couple friends who don't write who are as obsessed with the movie as I am.

I loved Napoleon and Nacho so I saw this in the theater, and giggled a handful of times. Since it's been out on DVD, I've watched it over 100 times. It's my all-time favorite movie. Not only did it get significantly funnier with each viewing, but the more I appreciated it as such a great story.

An example of the piss-your-pants-laugh inducing subtlety is the first scene with Dusty that I will spell out for those who didn't find the movie funny or this scene funny:

-the fact this guy who enrolled himself in the guardian angel program at his church, thought it would not only be a good idea to bring a python over to impress his little buddy but to also try to shoot and kill the kitten. First the python craps all over him and he's outside in a loaner jacket shirtless underneath, the latter being the hilarious part to me. Once they're outside...

"It's rat poison and some of my poo."

"Sick. Is it lethal?"

"No. Maybe. I don't know. Just do it. Circle of life dude."

Great activity and advice from a 'guardian angel'(lol).

I laugh thinking about the movie constantly. Another funny part is the scene that opens with Chevalier saying "Without a doubt, the best line I ever wrote was..."

The comedy is that someone asked the asinine question of what's the best line you ever wrote? Without trying to sound like a dweeb, perhaps that was a joke from writers for writers.

reply

By writers, for writers, and stoners. I'm pretty sure this movie is doing well on DVD.

reply

Yeah, this was pretty funny. Not great but it certainly had some moments. Rockwell as usual steals the scenes.

reply