MovieChat Forums > Public Enemies (2009) Discussion > Melvin Purvis played by Christian Bale e...

Melvin Purvis played by Christian Bale ending incorrect did not suicide


The details of Melvin Purvis (the character played by Christian Bale) are incorrect as Melvin Purvis did not commit suicide. This is an insult to the memory of this person and should be corrected. With little detail provided it implies that following the death of John Dillinger that Melvin Purvis committed suicide perhaps suggesting that he was 'disappointed' with his role or failure to resolve the issue earlier with less fatalities, as suggested in a scene with J. Edgar Hoover played by Billy Crudup.
The actual true story was that following the death of John Dillinger in 1934, Melvin Purvis continued to serve in the FBI until 1936 and then he went on to practice law. Whilst with the FBI from 1927, Purvis captured more public enemies than any other agent in FBI history and this is a record that still stands today. In 1936 he published a memoir of his years as an investigator with the Bureau, entitled American Agent.
In 1937, he became engaged to actress Janice Jarratt, but they never married. He later married Marie Rosanne Willcox, and they had three sons.
Purvis then served in the United States Army as an intelligence officer during World War II, reaching the rank of colonel. He assisted with compiling evidence against Nazi leaders in the Nuremberg trials (1945-1949).
Some eleven years later and 26 years following the death of John Dillinger, at 56 years old, in February 29, 1960, at his home in Florence, South Carolina Purvis died from a gunshot wound to the head. The idea that he committed suicide is 'wrongly suggested' because he dies from the pistol given to him by fellow agents when he resigned from the FBI. Although the FBI investigated his death and declared it a suicide, the official coroner's report did not label the cause of death as such. A later investigation suggested that Purvis may have shot himself accidentally while trying to extract a tracer bullet jammed in the pistol.
To fail to acknowledge this much 'life' and 'accomplishments' by this man including serving his country, simply to 'dishonour' him to sell movie tickets for this movie is a disgrace. I am also disappointed that Christian Bale did not have this checked and corrected. I am a strong admirer of Christian Bale and I feel he truely understands the characters and roles he plays. I feel that the character he played, would not have committed suicide and therefore this is at odds with the end script.

reply

Much ado about nothing! However he died, he died by his own hand. The closing text reveals that Melvin Purvis quit the FBI shortly afterwards and died by his own hand in 1960. It is not incorrect.🐭

reply

I don't know the full facts, I did read that epilogue and thought that it meant his suicide, but sounds like there may have been doubt if suicide or accidental gun discharge.

I can see and agree that if there is doubt, you should not declare someone's death as suicide. 'By his own hand" is definitely gentle language for deeming it suicide.It is terrible to say someone killed themselves intentionally, if they may not have, it being a sad epitaph.

OTOH, I did not take it as being connected to Dillinger or his FBI career, even if he did suicide.

As for FBI investigation saying suicide, well, why was it even an FBI matter, if Purvis was no longer an agent anyway. Sounds like a local police matter wherever he lived.
and, it being an FBI investigation...what were the dynamics at the time Purvis and Hoover?
You know what a vindictive evil *beep* Hoover was...what was his role in the verdict?

reply

"the FBI investigated his death and declared it a suicide"

Good enough for me...

"simply to 'dishonour' him to sell movie tickets for this movie is a disgrace"

This is absurd. Grow up.

reply

Back then, suicide was REALLY a stigma.
The guy dies alone with a gun....at home.
He wasn't at the gun range.
They just didn't want an FBI hero, the guy that got Dillenger, to be stigmatized as a 'loser' who is burning in Hell for the sin of suicide. So it becomes, 'he was cleaning his gun' and it 'accidentally went off' sorta thing.

reply