Would you kill Shirley?


I'm surprised they didn't do any of those. As soon as I knew some retarded judge let her to I would have made a decision. No way in hell will I let somebody that killed my family member run around and get another one. The father should have carried out the plan and make it look like an accident or robbery.



Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by rulers as useful.

reply

Honestly, I probably would've considered it, just like Andrew's father did. But as far as executing it, it's much easier said than done. It's also easy to say in hindsight, "Well Zachary would still be alive if Andrew's father had killed Shirley, even though he'd be in prison now..." Sure, it would be a more ideal situation, with Zachary living a full life and his grandfather spending only the very end of his life in prison while the grandmother raised Zachary, but at the time, they were probably just hoping it wouldn't have to come to that.

I also would've considered taking the baby from her like they said they thought about doing, but as they explained in the movie, Newfoundland is a very difficult place to flee because of the location.

reply

Yes.

reply

I would have highly considered it. Before watching this documentary I'd never known that I could feel such hatred towards another human being. She makes Casey Anthony look like a damn saint.

I've never fooled anyone. I've let people fool themselves.

reply