her blog was dreadful


It had no pictures and barely any text... the early days of blogging for sure.

reply

I love the film, but I couldn't finish the book. I read a good chunk of it, and Julie Powell seems like somebody who has no compassion for other human beings or at least the people in her life. She treated her husband and family like crap and took delight in making fun of them in order to make her book more entertaining. Amy Adams' portrayal was more likable. This is cruel on my part, but I can see why Julia Child didn't want to meet her.

reply

I didn't read the book/blog, so thanks for posting that. The portrayal may have been more likable, but she was still came off as utterly clueless, self-deluded and self-centered -- to me, at least. I was recently described as a "food snob" because I think it's strange to want to put ketchup on a $100 steak. I am enough of a snob to have cooked some of those recipes, and I was horrified to see her and her husband whacking at a Reine de Saba -- an amazing chocolate cake that has a fudge-like center, grading to a dense brownie texture and finally to a light cake on the outside. If you remember the scene, they were hacking at it from the outside in. It showed no respect for the food.

When it got to the end of the movie, I wondered if it had been badly made. It seemed as if the director was unconscious of this bratty little monster she'd created. Then it hit me that the Nora Ephron was giving us more credit than many writers and directors do -- she simply told the story and let us figure it out for ourselves.

If she was that horrible in her blog, that makes this movie even more of a masterpiece of subtlety. Usually a writer/director wouldn't give us any credit and would beat us over the head with her obnoxiousness.

reply

Well said. Yeah the character was still whiny and bratty; however I still rooted for her whereas the author (real person) I did not. I will have to watch that scene again. I believe food can be an art and like you said should be respected as well.

reply

PS if anyone did make it through the whole book and found redeeming qualities I am curious to know what that are.

reply