Didn't get the nod


"Crossing" didn't receive an Academy Award nomination. I am disappointed, but not totally surprised. Hollywood probably doesn't like movies like this because it makes communism look bad(which it is).

reply

Why would't hollywood like movies that make communism bad? that's what hollywood/USA is all about, against communism all for capitalism (especially in hollywood which is worst of them all).

Here's the final note though. This movie wasn't that great. It cut too many scenes, try to squeeze emotion out of parts that didn't deserve it (it would've gotten it if it just let it play out instead of begging for it IMO). The final scene didn't make me want to cry, it just pissed me off like Why the hell did I seat here and watch this entire movie for? I watched this in korea (i'm korean) and I've really seen alot better movies.

reply

Rowanok is right!
Hollywood has always been hypocritical. It does not like movies depicting communism (and for that matter Islam) as bad. It will reserve this only for Western culture, Christianity etc... Explaining the reasons is a topic not for this forum.
In sum, your comment narugirl is rubbish. "...de gustibus et coloribus ...", but if you didn't like the film then you should have left and don't bitch and complain (does a final scene have to reduce a film to a tear-jerker?). I bet you are a teenager.

reply


I'm with nanugirl on this. The movie was mediocre. But it's a movie trying to raise awareness for a cause, and as such, mediocrity is what is called for. This is barely a movie in a narrative sense. It starts well enough, but it dies as it goes along. The reality of the situation makes the film a chore to watch. The characters can do nothing to get out of their plight except survive. Realistic? Absolutely. That's what makes this film fantastic for organizations like LINK (Liberation in North Korea) to show at screenings. It's meant to raise awareness. That's the film's goal and I suppose it does that well enough.

But as a film, it's a bit of a chore even at 90 minutes. I found the first few tear-soaked scenes sorta moving, but by the end, I found myself very very unmoved. But that's me. Fantastic for those who were moved to tears by it. But that doesn't mean a film is good nor does it mean that it should be awarded with a Best Foreign Film Oscar (though I wonder why anyone still cares what the Oscars mean to anything anyway).

The kid was good. His extended crying over the phone got to be a little unintentionally hilarious when it kept on going and going, but otherwise he was the most interesting part of the film. Cha In Pyo... was flat. Didn't help that his character was impotent to do anything to affect the story, but he's just not a very good actor either. I don't think. It's been a long time since I've completely gone off of Korea's melodramatic performances.


"And that little one, is how papa gained freedom. Now, bonne nuit. Bonne nuit to you all."

reply

I also agree with narugirl and mcnooj82. They're took what is clearly an emotional topic and tried so mind-numbingly hard to make it into a sob-fest or something. All of the shots of him walking around in the desert, scenes with just like 6 minutes of annoying crying, that bike scene that kept dragging on for an entire minute. We get it, it's sad. we don't need to be spoon fed emotions. IMO, the movie would've turned out much better if they hadn't tried so hard.

Overall, still a good movie that I hope gets more attention. Just maybe trim and truncate some scenes to make it easier to digest.


Lisa needs braces. Dental Plan!
Pyle! Shazaam!
Can't sleep. Clown'll eat me.

reply

I was really moved by this movie, but I kinda have to agree with the last couple posters about the overindulgence in emotional appeal. It really wasn't necessary as the plight of the characters really speaks for itself. I agree, too, that Joon's story was by far the most interesting part of this movie. They could have followed him exclusively and I think it would have been a far stronger movie. I think it was silly, too, how they made the main character a former soccer player. As one of the reviews mentions, it would have been better if they had been ordinary citizens in every sense of the word. It didn't contribute to the character or the story at all whatsoever.

Still a great movie with an extremely important message. I just watched the whole thing on YouTube, but would love to find it on DVD. Definitely a must see unless you really can't stand force fed sob-fests. :)

reply

i think this type of movie probaly would not have sold well commercially, that was why it did not win. too real to reality that hollywood did not want to indulge.

anyway, the dvd is available as discussed in another thread called "where is it".

reply