MovieChat Forums > Saw V (2008) Discussion > Rank the Saw Series

Rank the Saw Series


I copied this from my post on a thread for Saw 2, but wanted to hear others' opinions that may have started with this film.

Here is my ranking:

Saw
Saw IV
Saw III
Saw V
Saw II

My ranking is based on my opinion of the series' originality.

The first Saw was the 'most original' just because it tried something fairly new, and despite its plot holes, was a good, suspenseful film. The acting was a bit off at times, but the scenarios, the motives and the ending made up for it, in my opinion. And like most horror franchises, I always have a soft spot for the first.

Saw 4, which I was expecting to suck bad, was actually really good, and oddly enough, tied all the new events almost perfectly to the events of the previous films (which as a horror film fan, I applaud). Saw 4 tied everything so well, and introduced the new Jigsaw in an ALMOST believable manner (though the events were a little TOO perfect...hey, it's a horror movie sequel). I must say, I was gripped at the backstory of Jigsaw (it was awesome), and the building up of his predecessor. Saw 4 had all the suspense, twists and gore that any horror fan would love.

Saw 3 was a decent film with a great main character (Angus MacFayden...sic) and a great subplot with Jigsaw and Amanda...though it definitely upped the ante with the gore as a main attraction (which kinda works, but gets a little excessive when you know that is the main attraction). The furthering of Amanda's character, throwing in Jeff's entire family, the people responsible for his son's murder and his murderer's release, and Jigsaw's demise made this one as good as it is. What a great film to have the balls to actually kill the main 'killer' in the third film of a seemingly endless sequel franchise.

Saw 5 was another good followup to a great sequel (and another one I thought would SUCK), yet the acting of some of the 'Final Five' really hampered the rating. However, it really solidified Jigsaw's successor, and explained a lot more of the plot. The Final Five trap really didn't add much to the story, but the real show stealer was the link between Hoffman, Jigsaw and then agent Strahm trying to piece it all together. Good story, and great ending.

Saw 2 was alright, but too much of a ripoff of the movie Cube for my liking. The acting was atrocious with most of the characters, and totally detracted from the film. Though, I will say, this was one of the more suspenseful (and cringe worthy of the films), the acting and ripoffs from Cube throw it down to the bottom of my list. This film could have been so much better with better actors and a better script...though the syringe scene is definitely one of the series' most cringe worthy pieces.

The Saw films are surprisingly good, and all attempt to link each successive one together (unlike the Friday the 13th series, though it is one of my guilty pleasure series). They are all good, in their own merit.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Wouldn't it be best to wait until Saw VI is out next weekend to rank the series, since it's so close? But anyway:


Saw II - 10/10


Best one of the lot by far, IMO. Jigsaw is at his best, I think the traps are the best of the series, I enjoyed Matthews' storyline and how it intertwined with the Traphouse games, and the ending twist was just as awesome and surprising as the original. Plus for me it's easily the most entertaining and rewatchable installment and the one I never get bored of at all.


Saw - 9/10


Classic, not much more I can say. Only real gripe I have is maybe the middle section is a tad long but it's not a big deal. If only the ending hadn't been spoiled for me, though :( Still, it's one amazing and clever ending, and still probably the best ever.


Saw V - 7/10


Nice throwback to the style and tone of the first two movies without being a copy of either. Loved the traps, Hoffman's backstory and the flashbacks, but it suffered from having the feeling of being too dependent on the other films for leverage, and the plothole with Billy being used in the first trap is pretty irritating.


Saw IV - 6/10


Suffers from erratic pacing, the worst traps, poor directing and I don't care for the Jigsaw backstory, but it's saved by having an excellent cast of characters, being thoroughly enjoyable and watchable and also having a good twist finale.


Saw III - 3/10


Aside from Amanda, Eric's scenes, the music score and most of the traps (except the Pig Vat and Freezer Shower), I despised this installment. Way too slow-moving, tries far too hard to be emotional but just comes off as boring and tedious, an overkill of comical gore that overshadowed the plot, an awful twist ending, Amanda's arc was terribly mishandled, Jeff was a terrible protagonist... I could go on how much I loathed this installment. The only Saw film so far I've hated and didn't enjoy one bit.

reply

i completely agree with you demon below just put VI above IV

reply

Saw
Saw II
Saw III
Saw V
Saw VI
Saw IV

having trouble deciding which is better V or VI. I didn't like how the health insurance dude had to do those games to decide others fate (a bit of a saw III rip off)

reply

Saw was great, really unexpectedly great. The rest, maybe with the exception of Saw 3, were horrible. The series as a whole, especially once they killed Jigsaw, is inconsistent and disjointed. Its possible that they have some big plan in mind that will make everything make sense but I doubt that (gonna milk the cash cow for all its worth regardless of quality). Plus the fact that they feel the need to crank out a new one every year is getting old. Absence makes the heart grow fonder and all that.

Well that's absurd. People are bastard-coated bastards with bastard filling. Dr. Kelso, Scrubs

reply

My new ranking after seeing Saw VI and re-watching it as well:


Saw II
Saw/Saw VI
Saw V
Saw IV
Saw III


Unsure if I like Saw VI better than the first or not. It held up MUCH better after a repeat viewing for me.

reply

It's hard for me to take them out of order. I enjoyed all of them and I am still not tired of them. I can't wait to see Saw VI. I can't think of too many other movies with sequels that didn't go south after the first one.

reply

1. Saw VI
2. Saw
3. Saw V
4. Saw IV
5. Saw 3D: The Final Chapter
6. Saw III
7. Saw II




*****
"Is that the one with the donkey and the chambermaid"?






reply

SAW VI
SAW II
SAW
SAW V
SAW III
SAW IV

SAW XIII-Jigsaw in space

reply

Saw II
Saw III
Saw VI
Saw
Saw V
Saw IV

reply

Saw II
Saw
Saw VI
Saw V
Saw IV
Saw III


More or less my final ranking.

reply

Saw I
Saw II
Saw III
Saw V
Saw IV

Looking at my ranking it seems as if the Saw films keep getting worse and worse from the first movie. The only reason I switched IV and V is because I didn't really like IV b/c it was hard for me to follow. I believe that the with each film, the series gets more and more complex leading to an inability to follow the characters.

I didnt rank VI, b/c I should be seeing it tomorrow. :)

reply

Saw VI
Saw V
Saw IV
Saw
Saw II
Saw III

reply

Saw IV
Saw V
Saw VI
Saw III
Saw II
Saw

Special Agent Peter Strahm 4EVER!!:)~NEVER die in my

>3Costas Mandylor-The Sexiest Villain!

>3Scott Patterson-The Sexiest Hero!

>3Donnie Wahlberg-The Sexiest Bad*Ass!

R.I.P.Agent Peter Strahm...Won't Forget You:)~

**BRING BACK AGENT STRAHM IN FLASHBACKS IN SAW VII**

"If your good at anticipating the human mind, it leaves nothing to chance."-John Kramer, a.k.a. Jigsaw

*Keeper of Strahm's HOTT body & Hoffman's SEXYY smirk*

~Proud Member Of The Detective Lieutenant Mark Hoffman Army!~~And The Agent Strahm Army!!:)~(ASA)

reply

Saw
Saw VI
Saw II
Saw III
Saw IV
Saw V

reply

[deleted]

Mine:

Saw
Saw II
Saw VI
Saw IV
Saw III
Saw V

reply

[deleted]

Saw VI
Saw
Saw II
Saw III
Saw IV
Saw V

Saw V wasn't that great in my opinion.
Neither was Saw IV but it tied in with Saw III and had that Eric guy so It's above Saw V.



reply

Saw II - 10/10
Saw - 10/10
Saw VI - 9/10
Saw V - 7/10
Saw IV - 6/10
Saw III - 3/10


Added ratings.

reply

Saw III - 8/10

Saw/Saw II - 6/10

Saw IV - 4/10

Sa3 V- 3/19

reply

Saw
Saw III
Saw II
Saw VI
Saw V
Saw IV

"You don't know what death is" - Samuel Loomis (Halloween II)

reply

[deleted]

Currently, for me its:

Saw II- 8/10 The most fun one of the series for me. Not to mention this is literally the only Saw movie I saw in theatres (along with some close relatives of mine), so in a way this added to my enjoyment of this movie.

Saw- 7.5/10 A good thriller. The twist completely caught me off guard.

Saw V- 7.5/10 I liked this more than most seem to.

Saw III- 7/10

Saw IV- 7/10 Remember it relatively well, needs a rewatch.

Saw VI- Needs a definite rewatch.


Haven't seen the last film (Saw 3D) at all.

reply