David Strathairn
I'm surprised that in all the verbiage about this movie, few, if any, have talked about the performance of the always reliable David Strathairn. For me, he stole the movie as the buttoned-down lunatic with the great suit and beautifully coiffed hair. He traffics in souls with the earnestness of a minister, and he does it all with a marvelously controlled straight face. And all the time he's a certified nutcase.
This movie was SUPPOSED to be a satire, but fell all over itself along the way and just didn't work. It wasn't a 'comedy,' or even a 'drama,' although it's billed that way.
And Paul Giamatti is a good actor, but he shows in this movie that he should stick with supporting parts.