MovieChat Forums > Kike Like Me Discussion > The only things worthwhile about the fil...

The only things worthwhile about the film


I didn't really care for this film. It didn't seem to go anywhere or have direction. The various ruminations were largely unconnected. And the filmmaker/interviewer did everything he could to come off as unpleasant and snively. That being said, I think there just were a few moments that were interesting.

1) In the Paris suburb of Sarcelles, the older men in the Turkish cafe said they had no problem with Jews. But the young men on the street seemed to despise Jews for no reason other than they are Jews. These young Muslims could not really articulate why. They claimed that a Jewish businessman, for example, would screw them over if given the chance, but they had no evidence.

Why is this interesting? Because it shows the groundless yet dangerous and misdirected anger of young (and unemployed) Muslims in Paris. Meanwhile, the older generation subscribes to a mantra of "we all have to get along."

2) The two interviews in Germany were very interesting. Non-Jews seem to like dead Jews and wish to commemorate them, but they ignore real, live Jews in the their midst. Non-Jews in Germany build enormous, expensive memorials to the Jews killed in the Holocaust, but they don't seem to care if the Jews living in Berlin don't want such a massive memorial or have other present-day concerns and interests.

The Holocaust memorial's initiator, Leah Rosh, whose birth name is Edith Rohs, is a self-promoting, self-righteous, pompous, deplorable person. She, a non-Jew, feels so connected to the Jews that she has taken a Jewish name and adopted a Jewish persona. But she hasn't actually converted to Judaism. She just wants to be Jew-ish, so to speak, but not an actual Jew. She does not share the Jews' theological/philosophical worldview. She didn't seem to care that a Jewish Holocaust victim's tooth should be interred as human remains and not treated as a novelty.

By the way, when Kastner made his flippant comment about somehow missing the boom in blond, Christian klezmer bands, he was obviously being snide. I can tell you from personal experience that the Scheunenviertel district of Berlin is full of Jewish-themed institutions, including klezmer acts, establish by non-Jews for non-Jews.

Those two moments in the film were the only things worthwhile in it, in my opinion. There are other discussions on the "KLM" board where the annoying things about this film are discussed, and I have contributed to those.

reply

I agree with you that Jamie's overall impression was snide and unpleasant. But given all the things that you said were "worth-while" about the film, don't you think that he has full license to be so? I don't know why, but for some reason I have always had a strange fascination with the holocaust from WWII. To clarify, it is inaccurate and grossly selective to apply the term "holocaust" pronominally only to the horrors that happened 1939-1945 (Stalin. Bosnia. Darfur.), but I digress. I had only ever seen footage of Auschwitz in cinematic, poetic, and utterly sentimental ways. I think for the first time, I have seen the aftermath in a brutally honest and, yes, very cruel light. Seeing the profits and disgusting tourist attractions really, well.. disgusted me. And the woman at the synagogue who deemed to charge entry when she herself openly claimed to not be Jewish... I dunno. It really pissed me off. I sometimes wondered what modern-day Krakow would be like but to find that even a little bit of it is like a Concentration Camp Disney World really makes me sick. Sick and very very frightened.

reply

She was Polish and do people forget that many non-Jewish Poles died at the hands of the Nazis? I'm sorry that you're offended that an old Polish woman was charging for photos to be taken, but I don't get how it would be fine if she was a Jew. It's very disrespectful to all the non-Jewish Poles. I found him to be very disrespectful and maybe ignorant to the fact that almost 2 million non-Jewish Poles died because of the Nazis... yet he takes his measly $5 back from the old Polish woman because she's not Jewish. For someone who seems to get offended when one asks him if he's a Jew, he seems to put a lot of importance on that question himself. Very sad and disrespectful.

reply

First of all, the scene on the street with the Muslims... well, they weren't all muslim. There seemed to be a potpourri of ethnicities and hues present for the anathema. So why put on the blinders and focus solely on the Muslim youths?

Second, I'll admit that making a memorial out of a death camp is unnerving, but should it be anything less? We could bulldoze it and forget that nasty bit of history until we're forced to repeat it. Or we could make it an attraction, a reminder -- a shameful ribbon tied around the wrist of society.

And Kastner's indignation at the lack of adequate representation of Jews where there are few Jews present was confusing. From the baseness of the title to Kastner's conduct, it was all so very combative and nasty. Definitely the kind of tripe that engenders mindless intolerance.

Apparently, Jews enjoy a priceless luxury. Asians, Blacks, Hispanics, and generally all non-whites never get to play power games with others who wonder what race they are. How awful it is then that Jews of European descent can willingly blend into simply being another white guy and essentially escape discrimination.

reply

[deleted]