MovieChat Forums > Lost in Austen (2009) Discussion > This was enjoyable, but I'm really irrit...

This was enjoyable, but I'm really irritated by a lot of things


First of all, I found this to be a really fun exercise in an alternative Austen universe.

That being said, I was really bothered with the fact that Darcy was smitten with Amanda. He loved Elizabeth for her intelligence and wit, and despite the behavior of her family, was able to conduct herself as a Gentleman's daughter.

Amanda is abrupt and rude, insolent and dull. Of the Bennetts, she most closely resembles Lydia. I cannot believe that Mr. Darcy would find her remotely appealing.

reply

Couldn't agree with you more

reply


Unfortunately, I have only seen one episode...the only one available on hulu. However, in reading this thread it occurred to me that Elizabeth was very much her own person, not unlike Amanda. She didn't let the aristocratic lot intimidate her in any way, she did things unconsidered ordinary, like walking and getting muddy, etc.

Perhaps what is attracting him is the unique individuality of the girls. ???


*********************************
I smell dead people.

reply

I wonder, Real Gideon, whether you're male or female. As a male, I found Amanda very cute and full of spunk (to use Captain Wickham's word).

Clearly the writer tried to make Amanda Price a Lizzie-like character of the type that Darcy would be most likely to fall for after driving him crazy for a while.

As in the novel, he initially despises her, just as she despises him. Yet, the rules of society demand that he behave at least superficially gentlemanly toward her, and her own mission of making the book-world turn out like the story forces her to deal with him.

Darcy does not respect weak, gullible people. He despises "harlots" and climbers, and although Mrs. Bennett and Ms. Bingley believe Amanda Price to be such a person, she soon proves herself to be an honest and honorable person who keeps trying to get others to do the right thing. Darcy is constantly watching her; he sees her refuse to take Bingley's watch as winnings in the card game; he sees her trying to get Bingley and Jane together, then he sees her teach Collins a lesson at the ball, at the cost of getting thrown out. And, of course, she is honest with him about her less-than-pristine past.

Truly excellent film.

reply

In the novel Darcy never despises Lizzy. He states the famous line of her not being attractive or worthy enough of his attention blah blah blah but in the same scene it's mentioned that he can't help but notice her, and that he's incredibly intrigued by her. He despises her circumstances which is what he's using to try to keep himself from falling in love, but, ultimately, he couldn't help himself.

reply