MovieChat Forums > Frontrunners (2008) Discussion > How smart can they be? (SPOILERS)

How smart can they be? (SPOILERS)


Truthfully, I hope there is a lot more to George than we saw in this film, because in every second of this film, he's an obnoxious, disapproving, vaguely shadowy loser. Pseudo-intellectual prattle about contingency campaign plans that will proceed in an alternate universe may sound precocious now, but if he doesn't look at how he comes off in this movie and cringe he's just not human. With a campaign photo that screams, "Hello world, I'm coming out!" and a running mate who just looks at him and shakes her head (and probably wins him the election given the school's demographics -- the only real smart choice he makes), George is someone everyone in the real world takes an instant dislike to, and his talk about investing in the "American banking system" makes him sound even more idiotic in light of recent events. With an ego that knows no bounds -- he actually asked Hannah a version of his jerk bowling coach's question "Why am I a better candidate than you?", only to see her blow it up in his face like a grenade -- he's the type of personality who cannot form the interpersonal connections that are the foundation for any political action at any level. We hear countless times how smart the kids at Stuyvesant are -- and to a large degree they acquit themselves decently, though the lack of info about where anyone besides George matriculated may be telling and they would seem to be eclipsed by the students at most decent private schools -- but any political body that would elect the creep we see here can only be so bright.

reply

Agreed. George was painfully pretentious, made up words and did not put together one meaningful sentence the entire time we saw him. He may get good grades, but there was nothing intelligent about how he presented himself.
I'm astounded that he got elected. Do teenagers just fall for swagger?
"Are you content to keep the bar where it is or let it get lower, and if so, what does that SAY about you? Give me the chance to raise the bar!" Ugh, it'd be hilarious if it had been said as a joke. Then again, this pompous kid has fake charisma, empty words and vindictive insults down pat -- maybe he *is* headed for politics.
Do you think they left in the clip of kids talking about Iraq because George's grandiose guilt trips were similar to another George I could name?

reply

Eh, he was just a high school kid and most teenagers are pretty stupid. I'm sure you guys complaining about George were all perfect geniuses when you were his age.

reply

at some point in the film, I realized that George totally reminded me of Anthony Michael Hall in "16 Candles" and then I just couldn't get that out of my head.

reply

Actually, George ended up at Harvard and biked across America for a good cause. And investing the money in the banking system is not unreasonable, given that funds invested in accounts such as CDs are riskless and FDIC insured, so long as they are under $100,000.

Yes he has an ego and yes he may not have seemed to be the most personable character. But you have to keep in mind he was not running for a real political position. The dynamics at one specific high school cannot be extended directly to the real world.

You also should keep in mind that he was about 16 years old, with minimal life experience. Mark Zuckerberg is not the most sociable person either, yet he has great potential, as we have come to see. I wouldn't doubt that he had a similarly eccentric personality at George's age in the film. But as is in Zuckerberg's case, having a certain personality flaw doesn't dictate how intelligent/smart you are nor how successful you can be.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, we were all idiots when we're 16, and he shouldn't be judged as a person based on this movie. Nor should he be judged based on going to Harvard (which just means he has a *beep* of money and a nice resume, bolstered by the title of SU president).

George's crowning moment was probably using the phrase "synergical force of amiability." Haa! I was vaguely disturbed by his idea that he should stand on a bridge to give everyone else the subconscious idea that he was superior to them...

Meanwhile, Hannah's idea for transparency in the student government got totally shafted in favor of George's investment schemes to earn money for: ?

Anyway, the teens in this movie really did not strike me as "gifted"-- more like "economically advantaged".

reply

[deleted]