MovieChat Forums > Shanghai (2015) Discussion > Best Swedish-directed movie?

Best Swedish-directed movie?


I saw "Shanghai" in Beijing, where on the cinema posters the names of the non-Chinese crew are also given in Chinese characters. As such I did not pay much attention to who the director was. Figured it must be some random American.

So I watch the whole thing, and love it. Film noir set in my favourite country? How can it go wrong? Then the credits roll, and up comes... Mikael Hofström. Possibly my biggest "whaaaaaat?!" moment in many years.

I have often been sceptical of Swedish film, as they all seem to fall in three or four genres that are all very cliché. Every now and then somebody will try to depart from the conventions, but with little success.

Suppose it's not totally unexpected from the guy who made the, to my knowledge, only Swedish slasher movie. Which sadly was not well recieved since people did not think the American slasher conventions fit into a Swedish setting.


My point being, this is the best I've seen by a Swedish director. Haven't seen 1408 yet however, Hofström's other movie with foreign cast.

reply

We have good directors working today. Never seen a bergman movie?

reply

[deleted]

Yes, I am 20, so Bergman was a little before my time. Can I make things right by saying I was talking about -contemporary- Swedish film?

reply

Please see EVIL which was an excellent film by Mikael; which was nominated for an Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film (Sweden in 2004). He has made two English language films prior to SHANGHAI. 1408 and DERAILED, he is currently filming THE RITE in Italy and Hungary.

reply

[deleted]

Ingmar Bergman is amazing. "Seventh Seal" is still a fantastic film.

As for contemporary great Swedish films? Hands down, "Girl with the Dragon Tattoo". It was everything that "Ghost Writer" was not, a great mystery thriller. Whoever directed it should be very proud of themselves. I also give kudos to Noomi Rapace for giving one of the most interesting female protagonists of the last few years.

reply

Lasse Hallstrom?

reply

Uhhmm, 'Tillsammans' ('Together') by Lukas Moodyson is a given!

reply

Let's not forget the works of Lasse Hallström! My Life As A Dog is a wholly remarkable film!

Everybody's got something to hide except for me and my monkey

reply

Yes, Lasse Hallström! Whats eating Gilbert Grape is one of my favourite movies in the drama department. Excellent film!

reply

The Virgin Spring is my pick.

reply

Pretty much every Bergman movie is fantastic, but you could start off with Seventh Seal, Winter Light, Through a Glass Darkly, Wild Strawberries, Smiles of a Summer Night, Shame and Hour of the Wolf.
But Sweden has produced more great directors other than Bergman. Alf Sjöberg and Victor Sjöstrom for instance. Sweden has been pretty succesful in the cinema over the years.

reply

[deleted]

Håfström is mediocre, the best (current) Swedish director is easily Tomas Alfredsson. "Let the Right One In" is excellent and I've heard nothing but amazing things about the upcoming "Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy"

reply

[deleted]