MovieChat Forums > Aruitemo aruitemo (2008) Discussion > Wonderful from start to finish

Wonderful from start to finish


What a simple but powerful film. I would challenge anyone to watch this whole movie and claim to not see at least one moment of family issues/politics in the film that reminds them of their own family. It's sad and yet beautiful. I don't think I've ever seen a movie in either the West or the East that captures so well the generation gaps in the modern family and the way in which the family of the early twenty first century is caught (or, better put, "stuck") looking both forward and backward. It also perfectly captures the complications of what a modern "family" is and problems of definition. Is it blood relations? Is it simply sharing a house and life together? These questions are left open throughout the whole film, and I applaud the writer for (unlike other films) coming out somewhat "neutral" and without judgement on which side is right or wrong.

A+ film, and in my opinion it stands right up there with Tokyo Sonata as one of the best films I've seen on family, and I'd say even surpasses it since the themes and dialogue work well even for a western audience. As one other poster stated, it is quite simply a "universal movie."

reply

[deleted]

Yes! Excellent insight, thank you! You're completely right and said it in much fewer words than I did. ;) The passive-aggressive nature of both the father and son particularly is so tense you could cut it with a knife, and yet they still sit and talk as if everything is fine. The whole movie you can just sense a million things bubbling on the surface, like a cauldron that is about to spill over.

reply

[deleted]

Oh yeah. It's incredibly simple and yet manages to be incredibly layered as well. And you're right, it doesn't feel like it's pretentious or geared towards a particular crowd (e.g. old Woody Allen films), it's a universal story about family and family politics, and the timeless adage of how you can choose your friends but you can't choose your family. It is also an excellent study of the individual as well, particularly the scene with the mother where she admits that she invites the boy over whose saving caused her son to drown just to torment him, because she cannot come to terms with her own feelings about it. Also the subtle affair between the husband and neighbour which is ever present but never directly stated (perhaps most heavily implied during the ambulance scene - his level of anxiety was well beyond the usual doctor-patient encounter). I can't say enough good about this movie. But you're right, afterwards and since then whenever I am with family and friends at least once during a conversation I will look the other person in the eyes and in my head I'm thinking "I wonder what they think about me and say about me when I'm not here." Sounds paranoid but I think you know what I mean. It's a movie that literally changed my thought process after one viewing, and I completely agree with you, I gave it a 10 before the credits even had a chance to roll. How they pulled off such an incredible movie that does not follow any of the usual movie plot formulas, and as you pointed out has no serious conflict, is beyond me. The only reason it gets a 7 on IMDB is because there are people out there who watch it and either A) Don't like it because it hits too close to home for them; or B) Think it's too "slow" because there are no explosions and typical movie flare such as a kitchen plate-throwing scene or physical fight between husband and son or brother in-law. If this were an English language film, it would have won best picture for sure.

reply

I completely agree with the previous replies. This is my absolute favourite film from the last 10 years. I believe it is every bit as good as the best family drama Japanese films from the 1950's, which was itself one of the high water marks in cinema history.

reply

Terry and Mandroidz, if you haven't already seen it, check out Kikujiro (original title: Kikujiro no natsu) from 1999. It is, along with Tokyo Sonata and Still Walking, one of my favourites. If you liked Still Walking, you will love Kikujiro. It explores many of the same themes, but does so more through humour and situations. It has more of a typical movie structure but it's done in a brilliant fashion and the acting is incredible. There are also some genuinely (and literally) laugh out loud moments. I absolutely loved it, so go find it right now if you haven't seen it! :)

reply

[deleted]