MovieChat Forums > Xin Su shi jian (2009) Discussion > I don't cry over rom-coms or chick flick...

I don't cry over rom-coms or chick flicks, but this made me cry ._.


*SPOILERS*



OH MY GOD... I'm actually still so very sad. I just finished watching this 10 minutes ago and it just upset me so much (well, moreso near the end)

Just the fact that Steelhead's brother, though did not want to take part in any of the crime and illegal activities, was beat-up, sliced, had his hand chopped-off.. that was horrible and ironic.

Then nearer towards the end when everyone Jackie Chan knew and loved died (did his older lover die to? Her daughter is too cute) and he floats away, then it shows the scene of where they present his brother with his chestnut stall.

I feel so very sad. :(

reply

thats so true.
the scene where his brother asks for his hand rather than water and jackie suddenly starts crying was so touching...


I love this movie

reply

I went ahead and watched this pathetic excuse for a film b/c of THIS POST!! And just like I imagined when I first read the plot when it first came out...it was cr-p.


When he has something to do w/ the film, other than acting, co producing, etc...he always puts to much on it in making himself the good Samaritan. It's to the point where he makes himself look ridiculous sickening now. In this movie, he turned snitch, not a witness, but a self-made thug MURDERING low life informant who testified to clear himself. Although he attempted to flip the script to make himself out to be the good-guy-gone-bad-gone-good, its not going to fly to well in America w/ the logical & intelligent. Even in Little Big Soldier, he played the cowardly saint..w t f?!!! And his endings are always cr-p when he helps produce or direct. I've lost all respect for this actor as Chinese actor. He's gotten to old for these type of films anyway so he better stick to playing goofy American parts





"You make your life what it is but there's always a point where fate steps in"

reply

http://www.metacafe.com/watch/yt-gnsyhmt7Brc/jackies_shinjuku_incident/

you should watch the video above, maybe you have, maybe you haven't, but it gives a little more insight into his motivations, and he's rightly so to be justified in doing this film.

Im reading in other little discussions "oh Jackie should stick to action/comedy", its for that reason I think he should stop, its a shame that Hollywood typecast certain races for certain roles, its a greater shame I think that (assuming most of you are asian) alot of you wish to perpetuate those notions.

No its not a great film, no, Jackie aint exactly a great emotive actor whos able to flesh out his characters with subtle nuances we expect from most other dramatic actors, but its a step in the right direction, and I think its the kinda step only someone like Jacky Chan can take, he might not be the greatest dramatist, but he sure does have a huge fan bases one that can gain alot of "western" exposure.

I haven't seen this film, but I know once I have, I too will probably come to the same conclusions that its crap, but I also will come away knowing that yeah its crap but its a step in the right direction, and just from the trailer I can see this movie will hit quite close to home for me.

Anyways, Ive gone on my little rant long enough, I just wanna summaries by saying, sometimes its not worth it to point out the obvious.... and then drive it into the ground with a 9-Iron.

(I like being a hypocrite)

reply

[deleted]

I can honestly say, that Shinjuku Incident is one of the saddest movies I have ever watched.

I have cried during movies, I didn't this time. I just felt broken. Brutal and touching movie.

The saddest scene is when everyone is turning on Steelhead and one of the guys is telling them to stop and Hong Kong Boy just sliced his neck. Overall, the ending was just beyond anything I've seen in Western television for years.

"Don't look down on yourself, just because other people do."
youtube.com/morbidchid

reply

I felt greatly saddened while seeing and after I've seen the film back in 2009. There are too many clear and obvious similarities to current societies and lifestyles where many people no longer seem to have the sense of respect for others.

Kinships, friendships, loyalty and honesty among others -- they are made out to appear as completely out of fashion as possible.

Self-importance instead, prevails and takes precedence over all other considerations.

People's hearts become extremely hardened just so that they could get, attain and satisfy their personal wants and needs.

Competing on all fronts, sacrificing anyone and everyone who stands in the way.

For me, I guess what made me felt sad was the realization that the very scenes depicted on the big screen echoed so closely to what the realities, life in these days has to offer.

PS. Shinjuku Incident is definitely a no-no for those who are suffering from depression and the likes.

reply

mfs void, agree with you 100%. Jackie has been a men who can kick ass and always make himself the good guy. This movie has shown me more about the man then the action man! Yes, this movie may not be a oscar movie but *beep* it was more honest then the othe *beep* movie like "Vampire Sucks"!

If something doesn't go your way, find a way to get it your way!

reply

I agree!! I saw this on a plane and it took my breath away, I was very very depressed afterwards. It was very well put together and the saddest parts for me were: when Steelhead floated away, when his "brother" was beaten up TWICE, when the Chinese migrants turned on each other during the uprising by the Japanese and Taiwanese gangs (esp when the Hong Konger killed the one guy who was always friendly with everyone), etc. All the while, I was really hoping that this would turn into a happy Jackie Chan movie that would have him beat everyone up so I could stop being so sad. Great movie!!

reply

Proves that the Yakuza are nothing but pig-headed scum who deserve to be shot to death whenever seen.

Let the world change the punishment for sexual-related crimes to execution

reply

T'was definitely a film full of tragedy.

reply