MovieChat Forums > Sukai kurora (2008) Discussion > Whats with all the smoking?

Whats with all the smoking?


Quite irritating.

reply

How is on screen smoking irritating in any way?
What's up with it is that soldiers tend to smoke a lot.
Smoking causes instant gratification and since they lived in a world where there was no long term gratification they chain smoked.

"Ah, nothing like a warm fire and a Super Soaker of fine cognac."

reply


.............This is an alternate reality movie. In this reality there is no Surgeon General.
True genius is a beautiful thing, but ignorance is ugly to the bone.

reply

I thnik the smoking is another subtle way where the director wants the audience to know that the kildren has no regard for their own health because they have zero memory from the past and it's like they know they're going to die young....if you notice in the whole movie only kildren smokes the "regular" folks don't...
also in the begining scene kannami told kusinagi he doesn't trust commanders who doesn't smoke.

reply

Actually, I just feel that it's a way of showing that Kildren aren't "kids" at all.

--
Abriael's gaming blog:
http://classygamer.blogspot.com/

reply

I agree. Kildren are shown here pretty much doing what other pilots would've usually done in their downtime-- which is drink and smoke and enjoy women (and Mitsuya even wanted to party 20 before that big campaign). Add to that the very, very short life-expectancy of being a fighter pilot and that issue of "not aging like everyone else does" which puts intense mental strain on some of them, then you'll understand what's the matter with all the smoking.

reply

How many soldiers do you say light up in an aircraft hangar with tanks fo diesel etc. laying around? Even half a century ago, this wouldn't of happened.

Never let your sense of morals prevent you from doing what is right.

reply

They are promoting the brand owned by the company sponsoring the combats. Just notice that all the pilots do smoke the same brand and take a look to all the ads placed at the Diners.

Regards,
Gonzalo

reply

Some good comments here but also, if you watch old War films about flying, particularly those set in WWI then you will note that the "Commanding officer that smokes and drinks too much in order to cope with the stress of the job" is a rather standard character.
At least part of the reason for all the smoking is, in part a "Homage" if you like to those old films (since Bay`s "Pearl Harbor" I`ve come to extremely dislike that term).
Incidently, they never light up INSIDE the hanger but just outside, still a bit foolhardy but not completely stupid, which is frequently what smokers actually do in a working environment when a smoking ban is in force.

"Any plan that involves loosing your hat is a BAD plan.""

reply

1.: It's the military. They are alcoholics and smokers because it's not like they have anything else in their life, prostituting lives for their oh so beloved state.
2.: Oshii is a smoker himself as far as I know so his work is simply influenced by himself.

_
SEUL CONTRE TOUS
www.myspace.com/anzycpethian
www.pbase.com/anzycpethian

reply

Not as irritating as someone who whines about people making the choice to do something that is completely legal and permitted. Why not whine about people driving a car, or eating potato chips?

I don't smoke, but it irks me that little whingers can't accept people who make their own choices...

..Joe

reply