this movie was horrible - U Me Aur Hum (2008) Discussion

[–] Inmateshardstyle 16 years ago

Well according to the critics and majority of the audience are loving it, it is also quite educational in scientific part and Love, Taran and Raja Sen have rated it 4 stars.

And you certainly have no taste if you rated Aaja Nachlaye a terrific role madhuri did, and this film crap, me thinks maybe its your personal problem with Kajol.

reply

[–] shanomi678 16 years ago

Keep watching and see how this movie is going to BOMB. It was so boring. What was the point of:

1. The little boy on the cruise..not funny at all
2. The other couples in the movie..waste of time...and really no point. (I really love how all of a sudden everyone decides to make up and be happy after Ajay's long drawn out speech at the dinner table "sarc")...
3. jumping back and forth between past and present with no good flow.

I am not a Kajol hater. I think both she and Ajay are great actors! I just felt this movie could have been handled better. The story didn't flow. The feelings between them never felt real. The way it was presented didn't make me feel anything.

As for my review of Aaja Nachle...yes it wasn't anything as far as a breaktrhough in cinema storylines, but it was entertaining, and it flowed nicely...and made sense!

The movie theater was completely empty...and all 5 of us who saw this movie agreed at the poor presentation of a potentially good idea. oh well!

reply

[–] saamzia 16 years ago

i have to agree-it was just an obvious copy of the (amazing) hollywood film: The Notebook

reply

[–] killernassir2002 16 years ago

the movie was great and your taste sucks

reply

[–] Inmateshardstyle 16 years ago

Yes, read his other post, he rated a terrible film like Aja Nachlaye to be great, and this one to be crap.

reply

[–] Gloria_Maddox 16 years ago

This one is crap and so was Aaja Nachle.

reply

[–] EvKaxy 16 years ago

I love Kajol and I realy wanted this movie to be good. Even the trailer looked grate. But unfortunatelly it was almost unbearable ...mainly because Ajay is a bad bad BAD director. Every second take was from realy strange angle or with strange lightning, strange lenses... I felt like watching circus performance. He tried too hard and the result was kind of tasteless. And there was no chemistry, no emotions between main characters. I didn´t get why they fell in love. Actually Ajay played a guy, who was stupid, rude, drunk and lier (not funny, not cute, not Shah rukh)and after two days of hating him (who wouldn´t)Kajol suddenly realize she cannot live without him...but honestly, he was repulsive and generally not interesting...the script was week (something between Notebook and Moment to remember), full of senseless time jumps, other charecters in the story was badly written and anoying and songs were´nt grate eighter...I was really dissapointed and believe me If there was anything possitive about this movie I would be the first person who would emphasize that.

reply

[–] drifter-123 16 years ago

Over all I thought both ajay and kajol were brilliant, and the chemestry was also very good compared to what I have seen in many other movies.

At the end of the day, the movie has made a great start and has gotten very good reviews from critics. Personally I loved this movie, it kind of reminded me of "taree zameen par".

If you dont like slow romance type movies then dont go to watch this one, but if you are into classy cinema then this is the movie for you. I give it 8 out of 10.

reply

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Inmateshardstyle 16 years ago

Sounds like a fan of Sharukh and Kajol Jodie speaking. Hindi films are not like Hollywood films to finish i 1hour and 50 minutes.

reply

[–] aally_v 16 years ago

i thought it was excellent, a terrific directorial debut for ajay.

i give it a 7.5.

reply

[–] Chrysanthepop 16 years ago

It was a disaster.

reply

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] shanomi678 16 years ago

For an amazing movie with scientific explanations of A neurologicl disorder:

watch

TAARE ZAMEEN PE (a fresh new idea)! Not this movie (an loosely based copy of The Notebook!)

reply

[–] Inmateshardstyle 16 years ago

Not a copy, its an inspiration,I doubt you have understood the film as your a brainless madhuri fan.

reply

[–] siddharthmehta 16 years ago

It puzzles me that you can write such a review for this movie. I'm not saying it was great movie but definitely worth watching. I do agree with many that 1st half was a bit weak and the other couples in the movie din't really make a impact.

But the central theme of the movie was amazing. The 2nd half raised the movie several notches higher. I fail to understand how the emotions din't hit some of you guys. I mean the chemistry between kajol and ajay was superb. The scene about the drowning kid was the most moving, I dont know how anyone could deny that. Not a great movie but definitely worth watching.

The very fact that the poster reckons that Aaja nachle is better makes his post lose all its credibility.

reply

[–] shanomi678 16 years ago

stooping to personal insults :) I can feel the maturity oozing from your comments ACMilan2. But I won't put much importance to that...since you have never met me (which is your loss)! :D If you liked the movie that's great! I'm just expressing MY opinion of the movie here!

reply

[–] presianpari08 16 years ago

im sry buddy this movie was bomb....i loved it and kajol was amazing.....yea it was no kuch kuch hota hai or sholay or anything like that but it was really really good and really different......yes it resembled notebook but i hated the notebook

reply

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 16 years ago

[deleted]

[–] uncle_g1234 16 years ago

This movie was exquisite. But at least 2/3 of it was for mature adults only.

reply

[–] uncle_g1234 16 years ago

This movie was the opposite of horrible.

reply

[–] SweeTGaL89 15 years ago

I thought this movie was awesome and moved really fast.. I didn't think it was slow at all.. I couldn't believe that the hourz went by that fast!!! I hardly rememer it being slow and not moving together...

The movie is NOT a rip off of the notebook except for the part about the alzeimerz..seriously.. this movie is different... I loved the notebook.. it's one of the best Romance movies EVER.. but I loved this movie too.. The elements on the notebook was different from the elements in this movie.

I thought some of the scenes were unnecessary.. BUT I liked how the pictures came together and the different lighting to set off the different moods and what was going on... And I think Ajay and Kajol did great.. Just cuz they didnt want to dwell too much on I love you this and I love you that didn't make there love story or CHEMISTRY for the matter any less noticable because I LOVED seeing them together!!!!

AND I don't think Ajay is ugly.. He is one of my Favorite actorz.. the way he is looking in the movie with the access bagz and dark eyez and all over the place hair is SPECIFICALLY for the movie.. I am going to say that he doesn't look like he used to.. BUT that comez with age.. It happenz.. ppl do change with age!! watch Ajayz earlier movies and you will cleary see that he is too HANDSOME AND SEXY AND CUTE!!! Yes.. I said it!!! HA-HA!!

reply

[–] vin99 15 years ago

1st half was boring .2nd half was the best peice of cinema i have seen in recent times.

reply