MovieChat Forums > Shoot on Sight (2008) Discussion > I don't understand about Ali and her wif...

I don't understand about Ali and her wife (Spoiler)


Ali seems to be an observant Muslim.

From the conversation in the car with Ali's wife and his nephew, I come to understand that his wife is not able to visit Mecca due to the fact that she's not a Muslim.

How can Ali get married to a non Muslim woman? it's against Islam and it's a sin.

reply

yeah that's why Muslims don't like this movie!

reply

im no expert
but i was under the impression that as a muslim you ARE allowed to marry someone of a monnotheistic religion (ie if she's christian).

dont quote me on this
but i heard this from my muslim friends.

reply

Yes it its true. Muslims are permitted to marry 'the people of the book' - muslims, jews and christians. I know this as I'm a muslim myself.

reply

I think fasx786 is correct. The whole thing about a muslim not allowed to marry anyone outside his/her faith is just one of the many false and extreme versions of the quranic interpretation. Though I might add that even though it's permitted it's not embraced open heartedly...in fact most people look down upon it. But it's isn't rare, illegal or forbidden.

reply

I agree with what @sodominion said. Indeed, Islam permits marrying the 'people of the book' (i.e Christianity, Jewish) However, it has been unusual for such marriage due to the differences in the interpretation of the religion each other is practising.


---
My Blog :
http://i1chocolat.blogspot.com

reply

speak for yourself, I'm a muslim and I loved it.

" Look, there's two women fuc*ing a polar bear!" - Fear And Loathing in Las Vegas 1998

reply

How can she be married to someone who is muslim and be surprised she can't go to Mecca?

isnt that something they could have addressed when they got married- by the looks of which was some 17 years ago?

reply