MovieChat Forums > Aleksandra (2007) Discussion > Before you see this film...

Before you see this film...


...don't do any background research! Really, if you just walk into this film and have no idea of the background (or very little), I think you'll get a lot more out of it.

I saw this film at the Toronto International Film Festival without even knowing what it was about (I saw it solely because of the director's name), and it left me wordless. I usually mentally "write" a review of a film as I'm seeing it, but here I really felt like there was nothing left to be said. I'm still loathe to talk about it at all, because I really think that it speaks for itself.

It's a stunningly effective film where nothing is verbally explained, but everything is very straightforward (no symbolism or suggestive editing here!). However, it was clear from the comments I heard afterward that it passed right over the heads of some people in the audience. My guess is that they had preconceived notions when they came in, and therefore saw it through murky goggles.

So please, when you see it (and it is worth seeing!), don't do ANY background research and just pay close attention to what you're seeing on the screen instead.

Because this is not a political film. It is set in Chechnya, but it is not ABOUT Chechnya; it could be set anywhere, at any time. Reading about the background will only cloud your vision in this case, and prevent you from seeing what is right before your eyes.

The director himself said as much:
"For me this story is not about the actual but about the eternal. Not about present-day Russia, its policies in the Caucasus, its army, but about the eternal life of Russia. War is always a terrible thing. In this film about war there is no war. (...) Our film is a work of fiction, not a political act. In the film, we are looking for ways to bring people together, and we find them."

___ __ _
My blog about Russian animation: http://niffiwan.livejournal.com/

reply

Shame that it had such a limited release in the States. I hope it will go to DVD before long.

reply

One can only hope. This is the best film I've seen this year; it's extremely rare for a film to leave me thinking that nothing more needs to be said.

It really is a self-contained, eternal story. Unfortunately, I think a lot of people were expecting a political film, and were disappointed that it wasn't like the newspaper articles about the war. I can only hope that with the passage of time, the politics will be forgotten and the film will be viewed without prejudice.

___ __ _
My blog about Russian animation: http://niffiwan.livejournal.com/

reply

A great film indeed. And very political imo, just not in the Robert Redford way..

Don't ask a dying man to lie his soul into Hell

reply

I don't see how anyone could see politics in it. The themes raised in it are eternal (or at least as eternal as humanity). In fact, one could watch the whole film and not even know where it is taking place, because the location is never actually mentioned (the person I was watching it with never realized that it was in Chechnya until she saw the name in the credits).

Heck, even the director said as much...

___ __ _
My blog about Russian animation: http://niffiwan.livejournal.com/

reply

I was born in Chechnya and my parents were murder there by wabaism Muslims who came from the middle east. They murder anyone who would not convert to there radical form of Islam. The rebels were not made up of Chechen people but outsiders and bandits.

reply

"I was born in Chechnya and my parents were murder there by wabaism Muslims who came from the middle east."

"Wabaism", you say? A fascinating story.

Listen to mine.

"I was born in Madagascar and my parents were murder (sic) there by naw aeg Buddhists who came from the far east."

Oh, and your user profile says "Biography Born in holy city of Kazan Russia". Kazan is in Tatarstan, not Chechnya.

I lol'd.

reply

I managed to find a copy and just watched it.

A fantastic film,now one of my favourites.



reply

Hi Mike. No bites I see.
Having fun yet? Oh well.


reply

[deleted]

[deleted]