MovieChat Forums > Aleksandra (2007) Discussion > Is her grandson really an officer?

Is her grandson really an officer?


I may have missed something through not watching closely enough, but at the beginning she comments about his 'old uniform' and then towards the end of the movie after he awakens her to tell her he'll be gone for 5 days he runs off and takes off his beret in exchange for a soldier's cap.

Is it supposed to be about how he's only pretending to be an officer so that she's less worried?

reply

Well, he has the stars of a captain, and that never changes. Then again it could have been that wasn't paying enough attention to note that... Could be that he's just two different persons, one around his grandma and the other a soldier, braiding her hair after he beat the crap out of somebody.

reply

She means old in the sense that it's worn, not old. He's definitely an officer or he wouldn't have been in the army those 7 years and he wouldn't have had the clout to have her visit. I guess there's a good chance he'll die and his men don't need the hat as a symbol. That's just my guess.

reply

I thought the commander said something about the grandson being one of his best officers. And the rest of the soldiers clearly defer to him as a supervisor. He is not just another soldier. He's also older than the heartbreakingly even younger soldiers under his command.

Is the beret an officer's headgear?

reply

i was confused as well about this gesture with the baret. Maybe they're remembering something from his youth, when he went away to become a soldier. Hmm.

reply

He was only referred to about 26 times as 'Captain'. Obviously not enough times to sink into your head.

As for the beret, he wanted to give her something of his, and he didn't have very much, did he?

I think it's possible to over-analyse scenes like that.

reply

I'm not sure if he had subdued insignia or not when he went out at the end, or removed them entirely, but he may have removed the beret prior to leaving the wire so as not to stand out as an officer to enemy combatants, thus making him a priority target.

reply

cuantas preguntas estupidas

reply

She says in the film when she visits the market that he is an officer

reply

She says in the film when she visits the market that he is an officer

reply