MovieChat Forums > Defiance (2009) Discussion > Praise for Russian Resistance fighters

Praise for Russian Resistance fighters


In my opinion, you kind of have to admire, not so much the Soviet regime, but the Soviet people for bearing the brunt of the German war effort for most of the conflict. Were the Soviet people motivated by fear? Sure they were. But the majority also felt a sense of patriotism for the motherland. Even those in the gulags were more than willing to do their part to force out the invaders. Perhaps if the Germans had behaved as liberators instead of as conquerers they could have won over the Russian people.

reply

Russians are amongst the most patriotic people I have met in my life. Their patriotism is not chest-thumping, flag waving nonsense like you are assaulted with in America, it is a quiet, determined pride and genuine love of the Motherland that far transcends government, politics or other credos. The people of this land have lived and died there for a thousand years, and share a connection to their home that is enviable.

This is also why Russia will never fall. It is also why America resents and despises them so much. They achieve with a genuine sentiment what the overwrought melodramatics in America have failed to instill in their populace- a near-fanatical devotion to the nation and its people. Their sacrifices seem horrific to us now, but they came from a different culture and background, and did not have time to wallow in sentiment or be selfish.

They valued the concept of sacrifice, a theme espoused in this film, and were able to make hard, pragmatic choices that many of us, in our coddled, comfortable cotton wool existences, would find unfathomable.

We cannot today imagine the unimaginable horrors they faced during war, having to make choices on a daily basis which resulted in hundreds of death, of whole villages starving to death, whole cities burning, entire populaces eradicated or moved, during brutal, unendurable winters.

They are tough as guts, the Russians, and I love 'em for it.

reply

In reply to the OP, "Soviet" people never existed. The country was called the Union of Soviet Socialistic Republics, consisting of 15 states that had hundreds of various nationalities. The majority were Russian, run by a non-Russian government whose composition was Russian as much as sand is in the Arctic. (Lenin = Jewish anti-Tsarist traitor, Stalin = Georgian, Khrushchev = Ukrainian, Brezhnev = Ukrainian, etc...)

As for the second poster:

This is also why Russia will never fall. It is also why America resents and despises them so much.
The 1st sentence, I TOTALLY agree with. Russia is a furnace that fuses different nationalities into a common identity and thus will never falter to a foreign enemy, demonstrated in their unity to expel the Polish in 1616 and form the longest-lasting common state not seen in Western Europe since Switzerland

As for the 2nd sentence, I could not disagree more. Americans do not despise Russia. They were taught to conquer and defeat communism. The Cold War was an ideological warfare between capitalist and socialist societies, where communism promoted (and still promotes in other countries) the equal distribution of poverty and capitalism promoted a lower class having the opportunity to accumulate wealth and prosper. Unfortunately the more communism failed into the 1980s, the more obvious it became that America was becoming victim of a similar system that has slowly been engulfed the country since the formation of the Federal Reserve System in 1913 and the rejection of the Gold Standard in 1971, both similar features to any fiat currency style economies of the third world. Russia and America were always allies, minus 1946-1963 and 1979-1988, who supported each others' existence from 1776 to today. We've been bordering each other since 1859 and despite the differences in diplomatic affairs worldwide, have ruled the world with the most advanced technology and brilliant minds seen in modern history.

Russians in World War II fought for their COUNTRY, not an ideological concept that was propagated in the trenches by the few in power, and thus were victorious in expelling the foreign enemy through a unbeatable militia resistance.

The rEVOLution continues! http://www.campaignforliberty.com/

reply

Americans do not despise Russia. They were taught to conquer and defeat communism. The Cold War was an ideological warfare between capitalist and socialist societies, where communism promoted (and still promotes in other countries) the equal distribution of poverty and capitalism promoted a lower class having the opportunity to accumulate wealth and prosper. Unfortunately the more communism failed into the 1980s, the more obvious it became that America was becoming victim of a similar system that has slowly been engulfed the country since the formation of the Federal Reserve System in 1913 and the rejection of the Gold Standard in 1971, both similar features to any fiat currency style economies of the third world. Russia and America were always allies, minus 1946-1963 and 1979-1988, who supported each others' existence from 1776 to today.



The "Cold War" between the USA and the Soviet Union was a propaganda fake.





Yours,

Thusnelda




Berliner Luft
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgKiAb5b2LI

reply

I just got thr your message history, Thusnelda, and I'm very curious about the sh*t you smoke. My warm advice to you: flush it away NOW. Hope it's still not too late.

Thank God, I'm an Atheist! - Luis Bunuel

reply

Excellent post, timberlax. Very well said.

Ahh, what the heck --- You too, Hannah.

reply

::The 1st sentence, I TOTALLY agree with. Russia is a furnace that fuses different nationalities into a common identity and thus will never falter to a foreign enemy, demonstrated in their unity to expel the Polish in 1616 and form the longest-lasting common state not seen in Western Europe since Switzerland

When the Soviet empire fell apart in 1990 it turned out that the furnace did not perform as well as expected. There doesn't seem to be much love lost here. Maybe it was mostly bloody terror then? In Estonia, for example, they were not that thrilled with a certain monument. The presidents of Belarus and Ukraine were poisoned but survived. And look what happened in Chechnya and Georgia. They were not happy to be a part of the common identity and what price they paid while the world looked on and did nothing.

::Russians in World War II fought for their COUNTRY, not an ideological concept that was propagated in the trenches by the few in power, and thus were victorious in expelling the foreign enemy through a unbeatable militia resistance.

Everyone fights for their country, not just Russians. And throughout history they mostly fought for their religion, as their leaders always in times of war stressed to the uneducated masses that the invaders wanted to destroy their holy orthodox faith. Plus there was definitely a lot of sometimes lunatic propaganda. During the Napoleonic invasion, for example, a group of prisoner Russian peasants begged the stunned French on their knees not to eat them and only calmed down after a long string of oaths that they will not be eaten. Apparently they were told by their leaders that the French were cannibals.

So maybe only not everyone fights with such ferocity and fanaticism as the Russians, and any prisoners are usually tortured to death (during winter people were for example drowned in rivers in holes cut in the ice). Remember that scene from "Europa, Europa"? The German soldiers shout to each other: "I'd rather be fighting in the West, at least the Americans take prisoners, while the Russians just kill everybody". For myself I admire more the Vietnamese for example, who are a lot braver and described by many to be the best soldiers in the world, as the Americans and French can testify - incidentally, there were many German veterans of WWII in the French foreign legion who fought for France in Vietnam, and indirectly for the Americans. Or some of the North American Indian leaders such as Pontiac or Tecumseh. Or Gandhi for that matter.

reply

America doesn't resent and despise Russia at all. The Cold War ended and Americans started flooding to Russia to do business. Diplomacy was resumed. Within a decade, relations were normalized as much as possible, at an astonishing rate.

My brother and I grew up before the Berlin Wall fell. He is now married to a Russian-born woman and my niece and nephew are half Russian. Their cousins are half-Jewish and half-Irish. American and Russian athletes are competing in Sochi and things are going fine, as well as they usually do.

Americans resent and despise Russians? That is such *beep* I can't even.

I was living with two roommates when the Berlin Wall came down. One had been born in Russia (Jewish) and lived there until she was 13, when she moved to America. We had a huge party and all our friends and neighbors and fellow students and workers came. It was the best party of the year. Everyone was so damned happy about the symbolic beginning of the end of the Cold War. It was an amazing moment for everyone, on both sides.

reply

::In my opinion, you kind of have to admire, not so much the Soviet regime

Why would anyone want to admire such a criminal regime? They caused more misery and death than all the czars put together.

::but the Soviet people for bearing the brunt of the German war effort for most of the conflict.

The attack on the Soviet Union and the destruction of the murderous Soviet regime that was the author of unspeakable bloodshed, starvation and misery (even if some of that was caused by negligence and stupidity) was the main reason for the Nazi invasion. The Nazis wanted to protect Germany, and especially the Eastern Prussia, from the communists. They did not want similar things to happen in Germany. So it's small wonder Russia bore the brunt of the war if they were the perceived source of communist evil whose goal was a global communist revolution, which they admitted openly when they tried to take over Europe in 1920 but were stopped first by the Ukrainian and then the Polish armies, heavily helped by the French, with Britain doing all they could to help the communists in their plans and sabotaging all help for their enemies.

::Were the Soviet people motivated by fear? Sure they were. But the majority also felt a sense of patriotism for the motherland.

The Russians were motivated by fear of the murderous NKVD, no doubt, but also by the Soviet regime's propaganda that played on the same emotions as in all previous invasions from the West. Is there any country in the world where the inhabitants have not fought for their country with a sense of patriotism? So why is Russia so special?

::Even those in the gulags were more than willing to do their part to force out the invaders.

Not too hard to understand - any chance to escape with your life from such frosty hell is a blessing.

::Perhaps if the Germans had behaved as liberators instead of as conquerers they could have won over the Russian people.

Germans were in fact greeted as liberators from the monster Stalin by the Ukrainians, and conquering Ukraine, with its access to the Black sea, rich farmland, and natural resources (it is often said that he who owns Ukraine owns Russia) was the main target of the attack. Ukrainians begged Germans for protection from this murderer. However, Soviet bands and whole armies hiding in the forests of Belarus and Ukraine (such as the one portrayed in this movie) caused so much damage (about 0.5 million German and allied solders were killed in Ukraine during this conflict) that retaliations on villages accused of collaboration with these bands damaged that relationship. Ukrainians were caught between a rock and a hard place, for if they collaborated with the Soviet bands they were treated as back-stabbing traitors by the Germans, and if they did not they were accused of collaboration with the invader by the Soviets and murdered along with their families.

reply

I'm so glad someone pointed this out. The Russians in no way have a clean slate in their history---especially regarding World War II. I also have to point out the mass rape that occurred after the Judeo-Communist victory in 1945. Although this didn't just include the Soviet Union, or rather the Red Army, the high majority was them. As many as 100,000 German women were raped in JUST the city of Berlin, as many as 15+ times each, ages ranging from 8 to the elderly. The numbers go on in each city, amounting to over 2 million women and children raped out of a civilian population of 2,700,000. The numbers are astonishing, and further discredits their image and intentions.



•¤ What can the damned really say to the damned? ¤•

reply

///the Judeo-Communist victory in 1945/// over 2 million women and children raped///15+ times each///The numbers are astonishing,....

...and your imagination is severely inflamed. Seek some help.

Listen to your enemy, for God is talking

reply

LMAO seeing how you ONLY reply to posts to throw your version of "insults" in an attempt for attention, and at information that is actually valid, with no attempt at actually discussing the topic at hand---I'd say it is you who needs some help. Though, I neither care nor assume you'll get it. Try some researching to get your history facts straight, though. It'll take you a long way than what you portray now, I guarantee it.



•¤ What can the damned really say to the damned? ¤•

reply

You're distorting and grossly exaggerating the facts, for the purpose to compromise the only Authority whitch was capable to defeat Nazism. That's rather annoying. Why do you need that? Do you just hate the Soviets (well, they weren't saints), or your symphaties concerning the sides in WW2 (let's say) are slightly different?

Listen to your enemy, for God is talking

reply

Ahh, there we go. The sad thing, dear aliza twito, is that I am not at all grossly exaggerating the facts. The fact that you would accuse me of such a thing, with those exact facts out there for anyone to obtain the knowledge of, if they haven't already, is beyond me. Though, maybe you are misinformed. I'd be happy to provide you with some sources for you to look up to see I am not remotely exaggerating.

And to your other questions---I do not possess such extremities as to hate the Soviets as you suggest, I am simply just stating the facts. This thread was meant to discuss the advantages of the Russian Resistance fighters, and it is only logical that the disadvantages would eventually be discussed as well. Everything has its advantages and disadvantages, it is never one-sided. Why must one be automatically presumed against a matter if they see its disadvantages?



•¤ What can the damned really say to the damned? ¤•

reply

Well, and what do you think about the massive bombings of German civilian objects by RAF, with an astonishing number of casualites? What for? Destruction of Dresden, widely known for it's architectural monuments, like Zwinger Palace? And what about Hiroshima and Nagasaki? At the same time not even a sole bomb was dropped on the railways leading to Auschwitz. You're not going on with condemnations now, or how about it?

///I'd be happy to provide you with some sources///

Oh, these sources... spare me kindly, please.

Listen to your enemy, for God is talking

reply

Once again, everything has its advantages and its disadvantages. The destruction by the British and U.S. in World War II are indeed disadvantages to their intents, just as the mass rape from the Russians was. I don't quite remember saying otherwise, do you?


And rejecting the sources concludes you refuse to be wrong, when indeed you are. That's alright, continue on your path of self-denial. And continue presenting other matters, such as the destruction from the British and U.S., as an attempt to deflect from your error. Go on, I'm sure you will.



•¤ What can the damned really say to the damned? ¤•

reply

And ok, now is when you got owned. Tsk tsk. A hero and a zero within the same movie forum.

reply

Um, the bombings of Dresden came after Germany carpet bombed London. Hiroshima was designed to end the war without full scale invasion of Tokyo which would've cost several million more lives. Nagasaki was because Japan was just crazy enough at the time to not surrender after Hiroshima. Luckily, the second bomb did the trick, or Tokyo was probably next.

reply

Well yeah, the soviets were in on the invasion of Poland, which started the war.

reply

There was no such thing as "Russian Resistance". Not in the real life (in this time period), nor in the film.

reply