MovieChat Forums > Lynch (2007) Discussion > Sorry Folks--its a total waste

Sorry Folks--its a total waste


I have to begin by apologizing to everyone who will be offended, but the movie is worthless. It doesn't do anything to reveal any inner truth about Lynch, as an artist, or as a Director, which is really disappointing to me, since I am also one of the many Devotees of the man. Most of us think of him as something of a Messiah, and are willing to worship at the altar of whatever the heck he drivels out, and so this confusing and unfulfilling documentary is exactly what we all deserve.

I'm about to tell the truth to anyone who's willing to listen: this movie is a waste of time. I don't think the person who pretends to be David Lynch (by using the silly name blackandwhite) is really much of a filmmaker at all, I think that he's just a film student who was one of the many that we watch onscreen, dutifully making David feel like his every whim is satisfied by pandering to him.

David Lynch himself is more than a little constrained by a cage of his own making, every so often admitting that he has no idea what he's doing, and feels a sense of inadequacy about much of what he does, He actually blurts out in one very honest moment that he's really very depressed, (but when talking to people on his website, he manages to convey a pretense of the opposite, and people seem to buy into it.) I have met the man and found him to be sincere, and an "aw-shucks" kind of guy, with little to indicate that he's anything more than a kid who inherited both a candy factory and amusement park, and just wants to give everyone a ride in the funhouse. David Lynch is kindhearted, and if he were not a filmmaker, would probably just be a friendly neighborhood eccentric.

But that doesn't discourage anyone in the audience, who all come to find some secret mantra about whatever the gobbledegook he prattles all the time. One guy in the restroom afterwards, in a desperate attempt to sound cool, stated, "I totally, totally get what he said about the fruit." (Yes, he said totally twice, just to make sure that we knew he got the hidden mantra of whatever the hell David said about art being fruit, or maybe it was the meditation being the fruit, or whatever else. (Most of what David says just doesn't stick in one's head, but no one would ever really admit it, they just act like it's profound so as not to seem uncool.)

So my friends, this is yet another blatant example of the Emperor's New Clothes, only this time the Emperor is somewhat loosely clothed in a buttoned-up white shirt and kahki pants (does he really have any other clothes, or is his entire wardrobe just one outfit?). All told, this movie is an unmitigated bore.

reply

Just like 'Inland Empire' ....Complete pile of crap in my opinion. I would class myself as a real Lynch buff but IE was something on another level, I felt as if he thought "wait a minute, I'll just shoot loads of random *beep* and people who want to act cool and pretend to be all pretentious will go and see the movie and hopefully will go buy it on DVD" .....unfortunately not David, I wasted 6 GBP on that drivel and I'll never get those 3 hrs back (yes 3 bloody hours...WTF).


Still, I do want to see this movie / documentary.

reply

i'm a big lynch fan (haven't been able to see IE yet though), but that was the worst documentary i have ever seen. it was unspeakably bad. that was a waste of 1.5 hours. see it if you want, but thought i may have a chance to spare you...

reply

[deleted]

you were brave to give it another try! :)

reply

[deleted]

supposedly the film itself (made by one of his camera crew) was supposed to be lynchlike-- the despot, the grubby back rooms, the funny angles from the floor up. but it just didn't work. i can't believe i paid top dollar to see it (at an international film festival, no less!), and missed another event (and another film) to do so! the guy must have pulled a lot of strings to get it to be seen.

it couldn't have been more contrastible with a really good docu i saw at the same film festival: the one about philip glass. if you like him, i highly recommend it.

reply

[deleted]

ok, at your own risk ;)

but try very hard not to pay for it (borrow it from a friend etc) or to pay as little as possible to see it... see it at home where you can turn it off in exasperation, and where you can go back and forth to the kitchen for beer and popcorn, which will be the only good memory of the movie and at least provide you with some consolation for your otherwise wasted time... :O

(as you can see, i am pretty annoyed at the waste of celluloid/bytes that this film represents!)

:D

reply

[deleted]

with friends like that... (!)

and: no wonder he has to advertise that way- otherwise nobody would go see it
:(

reply

is there any links to purchase this or download it (preferably the latter)

reply

fortunately, no!

reply

[deleted]

Lynch probably doesn't want everything about him to be known. I saw, and learned, a lot about the man that I hadn't known before. The documentary wasn't perfect, but it was balanced. It was informative without being too invasive. 7/10.

reply

i liked this documentary. inland empire however was my least favorite lynch movie by a million miles, especially after the greatness that was mulholland drive..

reply

In regards to David Lynch revealing he is 'depressed' in the documentary but trying to convey otherwise on his website...

There was one very candid moment in 'One' where he revealed that he was depressed because he felt he didn't know what the hell he was doing working in this new way. It was very clear to me he was depressed in that moment. I found it funny, because it was so honest, but I certainly didn't get that this is his permanent state. Nor do I see him making an effort to cover up his feelings either in the doco or at any other time (website, interviews etc.) He doesn't imply he's always happy. He's not pretending he's not human.

If you've ever created anything, a painting, a film, music, a book, you'd have to know it requires tremendous amounts of courage and there are bound to be some doubts and moments of depression about it along the way. Just part of it all. I found that moment in the film very refreshing.

reply

[deleted]

Man, I was about to buy this because I really want to watch him work on set (other than just special features on DVD's), but I guess I'll just Netflix this instead. There's been more than enough reviews on here to warrant that...

reply

Just watched and I agree. A particularly excruciating moment of the documentary was when Lynch was showing one of his acolytes the fairly unexceptional photographs of the abandoned factory he had taken and the acolyte is cooing these incredibly phony sounds of appreciation: "oh mannnnn... I love the metal.... OH GODDD! AMAZING! THAT'S INCREDIBLE."

reply