What is regarded as the ultimate 'Greatest Movies of All Time' list?


I'm wondering, is there a single list regarded as the most authoratative, accurate, etc. I've heard that the AFI is, I've heard Sight and Sound, I've heard the Oscar Best Pictures. I'm curious, is there a list that should be held in the highest esteem?

reply

Try this:

theyshootpictures.com

Overall I'd say its one of the best, most well-rounded lists ever to be compiled. I'm working my way through it.

Last film seen: Rio Bravo 9/10

reply

[deleted]

Awesome, thanks!

reply

'they shoot pictures' is a fantastic website, and i wholly endorse its endorsements. but it can be a little tricky to navigate, as there are numerous lists compiled in different ways (and all good lists). in my experience, it seems that the short and sweet list that is held in highest regard is the bfi "sight and sound" top 10 list, revisited every ten years (coming again in 2012). they compile essentially four lists: one for the top 10 films and one for the top 10 directors, one voted on by scholars/critics and one voted by directors.
for a list at a glance, that's the one to go with.
for depth, get into 'they shoot pictures.'
and while it's generally looked on with bemusement in the "serious" film community, i do enjoy the afi top 100 list for what it's worth.

reply