One film that got robbed....


Where was the good the bad and the ugly on this list that is a classic

reply

Oh, God, I totally forgot about that. How dare they not put that movie in?

The last step of insanity is when you're in denial of your own existence.

reply

That wasn't American. It's Italian. It's not eligible.

reply



FYC: Love in the Times of Cholera for everything!

reply



BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN and AMERICAN BEAUTY were robbed.







- - SoundTrak

reply

You're absolutely right about American Beauty. It definitely should have made it. I wasn't as big a fan of brokeback mountain though. I had nothing against it being a gay movie (honestly thought it would be a problem but it was handled well) I really just thought Brokeback didn't bring anything special to the table. Totally with you on American Beauty though. Plus I think a Charlie Kaufman movie should have made the cut. Even though I like Adaptation best, I think Eternal Sunshine or even Being John Malkovich were deserving of the list. Maybe in 10 years.

Your DNA must cry itself to sleep at night.
Save Studio 60, Save the world...

reply

[deleted]

I think that The Ten Commandments was robbed.

reply

The top rob wasn't Amadeus (though I put that second). The top rob was Doctor Zhivago which dropped something like 61 places suddenly. Apparently the Russian Revolution has lost its luster in this country.

---------------------------------------
Proud Yucca: Touch a button...things happen.

reply

i thought se7en and fight club could have been in there too.....

reply

[deleted]

I figured The Matrix would make the list, it really was revolutionary (no pun intended)

reply

I was waiting for it but it didn't appear...

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]