Why?
This has baffled me since I first heard it in the game but I was so shocked i didn't really know what to say.
Why did America not only got sh-ity voice actors but they also had to Re-Dub (Yes re-dub) the actual lyrics of the songs "Happy Birthday" and "Watashi no Mizu to Sora"!!! But OH NO not just for the English Dialogue but also the Japanese dialogue. The originals were very likable and well done for a voice actor.
I was quite annoyed with the outcome of the re-dubbed version as they sound offbeat and below average.
And Before anyone quotes Kingdom Hearts "Hikari" and "Passion" they atleast got Utada Hikaru (The original singer) to re-dubb them.