MovieChat Forums > Argo (2012) Discussion > Would Affleck have won the Oscar if nomi...

Would Affleck have won the Oscar if nominated?


Given that he wasn't even nominated for Best Director, it's easy to think that Academy members wouldn't have voted him as the winner had he received a nomination. HOWEVER, given that he won the Golden Globe, the BAFTA, the Critics Choice and the Directors Guild Awards (and over a dozen other Critics Circle awards), I can't see how he would have lost with all that momentum had he been nominated.

Anyone else think that Argo winning Best Picture was the Academy's way of apologizing for the snub?




Religion should be made fun of. If I believed that stuff, I'd keep it to myself. -Larry David

reply

Anyone else think that Argo winning Best Picture was the Academy's way of apologizing for the snub?
No, I don't. I think the idiots in the AMPAS "awarded" this ridiculous pack of lies because it flattered them, pretending that the phoney movie story had been crucial in the "escape". The truth of course was that the fake movie was completely irrelevant, and no Iranian official ever asked about the movie or cared about it. (And of course, there had been no "scouting of locations" in a bazaar, which Ken Taylor said would have been far too dangerous and he never would have allowed it.)

It was just a cynical ploy by Affleck to suck up to the Academy voters, by making them feel important and valuable -- and it worked. But it also blew the last thin shred of credibility the Oscars might have had left.

It was also typically ignorant (and arrogant) of Hollywood to think that a Canadian movie made by Canadians would have been controlled by Los Angeles, not Vancouver or Toronto. As if!

At the same time, even though the Academy members enjoyed having their egos stroked by this bogus movie, they were not going to pretend that Affleck had been the Best Director, when he hadn't been at all.

reply

no shortage of propaganda that year

Lincoln 12 nominations
Zero Dark Thirty 5 nominations
American Sniper 6 nominations

the idiots in the AMPAS "awarded" this ridiculous pack of lies

reply

Yeah probably

reply

a fake movie.

reply

He would have had a really good chance yeah.

reply