MovieChat Forums > Argo (2012) Discussion > The guard calls an American phone number...

The guard calls an American phone number? Why not a Canadian one?


If the film crew is CANADIAN and the film is produced by CANADIANS, then why give the guard at the end (him of all people) a number to a line in the USA?

🐾

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

You're delusional. When have I ever talked to myself? They try to stifle one voice? Fine, I'll use another. And it's interesting to see perceptive people agreeing with me --and somehow their messages are NOT deleted.

Freedom of Speech doesn't apply to internet sites. They have rules and guidelines. They can remove comments, or users, any time they like.
What's "hysterically sad" is your eagerness to make feeble excuses for the fact that you HAVE no freedom of speech, here or anywhere else. That's just the ugly truth.

Admit it: You either say what your fascist masters will LET you say, or you resign yourself to the fact that they'll try to stifle you -- and they'll probably succeed.

And that's supposed to be a democracy?? Where I come from, freedom of speech actually means something. It's not just one of your ludicrous "four freedoms", all of which fall apart immediately on closer examination.

How deluded does it get? It's sad, really.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Why in hell is it such a PROBLEM for anybody if I simply answer your question?? Is Affleck paying this site to delete any message that points out what a huge pile of manure his movie was? The "Oscar" is becoming more and more devalued -- and when they give their bogus "Best Picture" to this ridiculous piece-of-crap movie, it shows that it has lost its value completely.

If the film crew is CANADIAN and the film is produced by CANADIANS, then why give the guard at the end (him of all people) a number to a line in the USA?
Some idiot reported my reply to you and got it deleted (some people just can't handle reality and truth), so here it is again:

Affleck was so eager to suck up to Hollowood that he continued to insult Canada by ignorantly and arrogantly pretending that a CANADIAN movie being made by Canadians would be controlled by Los Angeles, rather than Vancouver or Toronto. That's just insulting.

And it seems that the writers were not smart enough to understand that calling the U.S. for "confirmation" would have blown their cover completely.

It shouldn't surprise you, though, to know that the truth is that the fake movie was completely unnecessary, since no Iranian official ever asked about it or cared -- and that ALL that ridiculous suspense nonsense at the end was bogus. None of it ever happened.

reply

What on earth happened on this thread while I was away? Turn my back for a few months and poof, I come back to something that looks like the dumpster in the backlot of a slaughterhouse.

🐾

reply

What on earth happened on this thread while I was away?
The problem with this board is that there are nasty-minded twits who think it's clever to REPORT any opinion they don't like or disagree with -- AND there are people whose messages are regularly deleted, no matter how harmless and accurate they are, "by an administrator". (Where are they finding these people? Don't they give them ANY training??)

It's time for Americans to admit that the truth is they have no "freedom of speech" at all. They're only allowed to say something that the powers-that-be will agree with. Otherwise, it's gone. That's fascism, pure and simple.

But I believe that the first comment in reply to your message was that it was just typical of Hollowood ignorance and ARROGANCE that they would assume that a Canadian movie being made by Canadians would be controlled by Los Angeles, rather than Vancouver or Toronto. That was just insulting and offensive. But of course, if you say so, they try to stifle you.....

And of course, when the filmmakers added that fictional bit of b.s. to a script that was already full of it, they weren't smart enough to realize that, if an official was supposed to phone the U.S. for "corroboration", their cover would have been blown completely!  The stupidity was just breath-taking.

reply

Ok, thanks for explaining and recalling that comment. Sorry this discussion got hijacked by snitches who report. (I am with you in spirit but IMDb can do what they want here. First Amendment only covers what the govt is allowed to do to restrict speech. IMDb owns this domain, can set their own rules and enforce them arbitrarily.)


Yeah, the phone call to the US was a huge, arrogant goof.




🐾

reply

Sorry to add to all the drama here and apologies if it's already been mentioned (so many comments deleted) but why can't a Canadian film company have offices in Los Angeles? Plenty of American-owned film companies have offices in Canada. I see no problem with giving the guard an American phone number.

reply

why can't a Canadian film company have offices in Los Angeles?
Nowadays, they do, but it wasn't that common in 1978. Lion's Gate was originally a Vancouver company that recently moved to L.A.
I see no problem with giving the guard an American phone number.
Except that when they were trying to pretend that it was a Canadian film being made by Canadians, and that the six Americans were really Canadian, they should have distanced themselves as much as possible from the U.S.

Making it look like the movie was being controlled by L.A. would have raised suspicions all over.

I saw it as just part of Hollywood's ignorance and arrogance that they'd assume they'd be controlling everything. Even back then, Canada had it's OWN film industry, which would have been controlled by Vancouver or Toronto.

reply

Except that when they were trying to pretend that it was a Canadian film being made by Canadians, and that the six Americans were really Canadian, they should have distanced themselves as much as possible from the U.S.

Making it look like the movie was being controlled by L.A. would have raised suspicions all over.

I saw it as just part of Hollywood's ignorance and arrogance that they'd assume they'd be controlling everything. Even back then, Canada had it's OWN film industry, which would have been controlled by Vancouver or Toronto.


True, you make some good points here. The CIA agent should have recruited a director and producer in Vancouver or Toronto, and had the script reading and launch party in one of those cities too. Well, I guess some people are so enamored by Hollywood it gets in the way of being practical. This movie probably wouldn't have been made either.

reply

Had the same question. Why would a CIA give an American phone number to the Revolutionary Guard at the airport? These guys were supposed to be the elite of the elite, fluent in English, educated overseas, blah blah blah. Yet when they are handed a business card with an American phone number and address on it, they are totally cool with it? WTF?

Also why didn’t Kevin Harkins stay at the Canadian Ambassador’s house with the rest of the “film crew”? Wouldn’t the Iranians see him taxi across the city to his hotel every night and wonder why the others stayed behind?

reply

The guard called the number of the production company the "Canadians" claimed to work for. It was that simple.

Did not actually happen of course. Other than the fact that some Americans hide out in the residence of the Canadian ambassador and the CIA sent an agent into help get them out, most of the film was a work of fiction with most of the scenes shown not really happening in real life.

reply