Completely Awful


I just saw a special screening of this "movie" at Northwestern University and I have to say that calling it utter crap would be an understatement. The only possible way I could see the director and the writers conceiving this hyper unrealistic plot is for them to be trying to make the worst movie ever. If this was their plan then bravo, you succeeded!

A moment that characterizes this is in a love scene when the protagonist is with mischa barton. Barton tries to deliver her lines in a serious manner yet the scene generated howling laughter from the entire audience.

The entire theatre I saw it with agreed on how bad it was and we spent hours discussing how surreal the experience was. I actually would reccomend this movie to anyone just so they can witness the bottom of the barrel in terms of film making. I sort of how it was one sick joke.

reply

Hmmm. I dont beleive you for some reason....Since the film has gotten good reviews so far. Maybe you didnt like it. Dont be such a drama queen and say the entire audiance hated it.

................... .................... ....________
............ ................... .....,.-‘”.......... .........``~.,
................... ..........,.-”...... .................... .........“-.,
................... ......,/............ .................... ...............”:,
................... ..,?................ .................... ..................\,
................... /................... .................... .................... ,}
................./. .................... .................... .............,:`^`.. }
.............../... .................... .................... ........,:”......... /
..............?.... .__................. .................... ....:`.........../
............./__.(. ....“~-,_........... ..................., :`........../
.........../(_....” ~,_........“~,_..... ...............,:`.. ......_/
..........{.._$;_.. ....”=,_.......“-,_. ......,.-~-,},.~”;/. ...}
...........((.....* ~_.......”=-._...... “;,,./`..../”....... ......./
...,,,___.\`~,..... .“~.,............... .....`.....}........ ....../
............(....`= -,,.......`......... ...............(.... ..;_,,-”
............/.`~,.. ....`-.............. .................\.. ..../\
.............\`~.*- ,................... ..................|, ./.....\,__
,,_..........}.> -._\................ ...................| ..............`=~-,
.....`=~-,_\_...... `\,................. ................\
................... `=~-,,.\,........... .................... \
................... .............`:,,... .................... ....`\.............. __
........... ................... .......`=-,......... ..........,%`>--= =``
................... .................... ._\..........._,-%.. .....`\
................... ................,< ;`.._|_,-&``........ ........`\

reply

you see that's the thing I thought i was being cynical in my reaction but at least 75% of the 100 or so people in the theater were embarrassed to have seen it.

It hasn't really had any true reviews just some fanboys who want to see mischa barton's nipples.

reply

Was Mischa nekkid?

reply

ok, I have to put my two cents in.....

I worked on the film, and I happen to like it. Before you berate me, yes! I know Mischa Barton is an idiot and I could tell you horror stories, but I love Reece. I liked the style of the film, and if you didn't then you probably didn't get it. No harm intended in that comment!

The film is supposed to be a tribute to the old Nior Detective films mixed with all the crappy high school drama that YES does happen in the real word.

It may not have happened at your school, but I guarantee it did happen.

So I respectfully disagree with your opinion but it is still your opinion.

reply

[deleted]

I'll give you this much the music was good, but the rest seemed pretty lazy, lines like "I want you, well you can have me" or "my parents aren't home. you could be my daddy" where just too ridiculous to believe, and I think you mean film NOIR

reply

"The film is supposed to be a tribute to the old Nior Detective films mixed with all the crappy high school drama that YES does happen in the real word."


Oh really? Then everyone watch Brick instead.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

i third!
If you want to see high school film noir, Brick is the ONLY way to go.
And if you liked Brick, check out Miller's Crossing

reply

DEFINITELY

not sure how this one will turn out, but Brick is fantastic

reply

I saw this film at Sundance and it is very different from Brick. The fact that they are both about high school kids investigating a mystery in the style of a film noir is the only thing in my mind that connects the two. Other than that this movies is a comedy noir. It's extremely hilarious throughout and the mystery is also incredibly intriguing. Mischa Barton is nude in the film but probably not the way all you masturbating dudes wish she was. They didn't just think "hey! we'll get everyone to come to our film by having Barton naked!" The scene is effective, heartbreaking, and hilarious all at the same time. I can't wait to watch this film again. And if you didn't like it then I guess it wasn't your kind of movie but please don't paint it as a huge dud of a film because then you'll scare away the people who will enjoy this film.

reply

I agree. Brick was a trillion times better than this

reply

Well, that correction of the spelling of "noir" was certainly obnoxious.

But I guess you've never accidentally switched two letters while tpying (see what I did there?).

In any case, I haven't seen the movie so I can't vouch for its quality, but a line like "my parents aren't home. you could be my daddy" sounds exactly like the right kind of thing for a teen movie satarizing film noir.

Consider this rapid-fire dialogue scene (an all-time classic noir sequence) from 1944's Double Indemnity:

Phyllis: Mr. Neff, why don't you drop by tomorrow evening about eight-thirty. He'll be in then.
Walter Neff: Who?
Phyllis: My husband. You were anxious to talk to him weren't you?
Walter Neff: Yeah, I was, but I'm sort of getting over the idea, if you know what I mean.
Phyllis: There's a speed limit in this state, Mr. Neff. Forty-five miles an hour.
Walter Neff: How fast was I going, officer?
Phyllis: I'd say around ninety.
Walter Neff: Suppose you get down off your motorcycle and give me a ticket.
Phyllis: Suppose I let you off with a warning this time.
Walter Neff: Suppose it doesn't take.
Phyllis: Suppose I have to whack you over the knuckles.
Walter Neff: Suppose I bust out crying and put my head on your shoulder.
Phyllis: Suppose you try putting it on my husband's shoulder.
Walter Neff: That tears it.

Too ridiculous? Well, I'm willing to wager that is the kind of dialogue the film-makers had in mind when they were writing lines like the ones you gave examples of.

reply

[deleted]

**spoilers**




this movie is a comedy built over a noir homage/thriller. the audience laughing at those lines is the correct response, even if they were laughing for the wrong reason. she is playing him for a sucker the whole movie, and all those lines are supposed to sound that way because it's letting you, the audience member, know she's conning him.

i thought the movie was fairly well done overall, and while it's easy to want to compare this to Brick, Brick was playing it straight while this was supposed to be a comedy overall and it's using the noir homage/thriller template to do it. the humor is occasionally more subtle than some people appear to realize.

reply

[deleted]

I thought this film was brilliant....subtley wrapped in recognizable parody. Sublime in it's obvious nods to the cliched corn of the film noir genre. (Oxymorons intended), hilarious! Loved the writing, loved the acting (for the most part), loved Reece Thompson (I think he's really under utilized in Hollywood!), loved the characters (they were so awful and crude in such a compelling way, lol)and loved the camera shots and angles. Favourite scene: beer pong...so perfectly blocked, shot and executed, from Reece's FUNKE and sexy dance moves to the high school newspaper chick enhancing the scene (loved how her dance and feather boa contrasted with the teenage choice of plastic drinking cup,haha). Drunk chick at party loses balance and knocks over the lamp, breaking the spell along with it. Great laughs! I'd like to see the out-takes on this film too, especially the scene where Bruce Willis has the bad boys lined up giving them the old sarge routine...I bet they had to shoot that one a few times, don't know how the could have kept a straight face, haha. Yeah, I really liked this movie a whole lotta levels!!

reply

P.S. Did I mention I also loved the music and where they placed it in the scenes (especially the already mentioned beer pong bit)? Brill!

reply

I loved Reece Thompson too, especially with that gum chewing. However, he knew how to be a follower. I'm dead serious. Later on in the movie when Franchesca was involved with Bobby Funke, he did display moves like a follower would. Basically, that girl never liked him nor Paul. She used both of them. They were like dogs on a leash. That's what it reminded me of when Franchesca got caught. I guess you can say you he was still wearing a dog leash around his neck. Bobby's classmates told him that girl was using him and he didn't listen. He realized that he became Franchesca's dog too. She told him to do something and Bobby did it, especially when he engaged in intercourse. He really let her tug on his leash. Better yet, picture Bobby and Paul getting belly rubs by Franchesca. How pathetic is that? I was shocked and disgusted by the ending when I found out she was behind the stolen SAT exam because that's what it reminded me of. Like Bobby said "You played me, you played Paul, you played the whole d--- school." In the end, he walked away like a man, but I liked the fact that Clara Diaz did the honors of tugging on his leash away from Franchesca the she-devil when she tugged on his jacket. That was romantic and cool. He stood up for what he believed in and got his leash tugged one more time. For the record, I think Bobby ended up with a new girlfriend which was Clara. He liked her too. I think she really liked him.

reply

i liked the movie

reply

"you see that's the thing I thought i was being cynical in my reaction but at least 75% of the 100 or so people in the theater were embarrassed to have seen it."

So, are we to believe that you interviewed 100 people that you saw the movie with and at least 75 of them said they were embarrassed to have watched it?

I'm sorry, m5, but you are much less believable than the film could ever be.

In fact, I can only conclude that you are a flat-out liar, for whatever purpose.

You didn't even watch the movie, did you?

"It hasn't really had any true reviews just some fanboys who want to see mischa barton's nipples."

BTW, the last time that I saw Mischa's nipples was in the movie, "Lawn Dogs". They didn't do anything for me then, either. She was 11.

It's her eyes, m, it's her eyes.

If I want to see nipples, I pull out a Marisa Tomei movie.


Ask your doctor if thinking is right for you

reply

I didn't even finish watching it. It was so lame and boring I just couldn't endure the waste of my time!

reply

An unrealistic plot in a movie! Why that is absurd. My brain can not handle such a thing, I thought everything in a movie had to be realistic, that is exactly why I watch movies. There is nothing quite like coming home from a day at work and then watching a movie about my day at work. I simply could not enjoy myself if a movie exaggerated what really happens in life, that would be preposterous.

reply

Very derivative (Brick) the question is why not make a film noir. Why not make an actual film noir.

reply

[deleted]

I have to agree, this film was tediously boring. Bruce Willis must have done this as a favour because his career hasn’t gone this downhill yet. Mischa Barton although looking lovely is starting to become a complete turn off when it comes to choosing a film after seeing her pathetic blog site ‘shrine’ and here roller-coaster life style.

I WANT 1 ½ HOURS OF MY LIFE BACK.

reply

Belongs in the all time worst list, who rigged the poll to give it the high review it currently has? The only thing good in this is the music!

reply

"I WANT 1 ½ HOURS OF MY LIFE BACK."

By reducing your sleep from 6 hours a night to 5½ a night, you would be able to reclaim approximately 183 hours a year, or about 2 movies per week. And if you sleep through the movies, you won't even miss any sleep.

Also, you won't ever get bored at the movies again.

Ask your doctor if thinking is right for you

reply

"""I just saw a special screening of this "movie" at Northwestern University and I have to say that calling it utter crap would be an understatement. The only possible way I could see the director and the writers conceiving this hyper unrealistic plot is for them to be trying to make the worst movie ever. If this was their plan then bravo, you succeeded!"""

This makes me question how many movies you have seen in your life. Two, maybe? Come on. There's nothing in this movie that justifies calling it utter crap and even less so the good old tired "w0rss m0vee 0v all tim3z!".

I could very well understand someone not being impressed by this film or disliking it but buy yourself a clue and get some perspective, will you. I almost skipped this movie because of your comments and am sure glad I gave it a try. I was afraid it might be a cheap way to cash in on Brick's critical success but very much enjoyed the movie.

The direction was solid, the plot is standard noir territory but is paced very well, most of the cast was adequate and there are several great comedy moments.

On the downside, I thought Reece Thompson was a little lackluster as the lead. To his defense the character is a little bland and lacks a bit of originality. Some peripheral characters could have used a few more scenes as well. And lastly, while I appreciate the effort to walk the fine line between harsh movie and mainstream, I think this film would have benefitted from going one direction or the other. It feels at times like the director was not sure if he wanted to make a PG-13 or an R film.

reply

I don't understand how someone could be so stupid that they criticize a self-proclaimed "high school-noir genre blend" as being "unrealistic."

NO FCKING SHT YOU FCKING MORON, IT'S NOT SUPPOSED TO BE REALISTIC.

Haven't seen it, I've heard it's good though.

reply


Jesus Christ...

C'mon people...This movie is not a rip off of "Brick," this movie is basically a remake of "Chinatown." You know, a classic? Three pages of comments and not one mention of Chinatown. Really? It even lifted some dialogue and scenes from the movie.

I enjoyed this movie, it was good. Bruce Willis' performance was great and I didn't notice Ms. Barton's bad acting. I think you need to take the movie for what it is.

reply

Dunno if it was a remake or something, but it definitely wasn't bad, though not one of the movies you're gonna watch again.

reply

"Jesus Christ...

C'mon people...This movie is not a rip off of "Brick," this movie is basically a remake of "Chinatown." You know, a classic? Three pages of comments and not one mention of Chinatown. Really? It even lifted some dialogue and scenes from the movie."

Precisely. How can I take the opinions seriously when not one person here mentions the obvious. Have you people seen Chinatown? For christ sakes, the last line in this film is lifted right from the last friggin line in Chinatown.

Personally, I felt the film was extremely well done. It's comparisons to Brick are only half warranted. However, unlike Brick, this film knew not to take itself seriously. Brick was a good movie, but in a different way. This movie is fun, with a good mystery, some good noir dialogue, and some great performances from Willis and Thompson.

I don't understand why people think this is so terrible. Yes, it's exaggerated, but not by much. It's high school, kids do and say dumb stuff all the time. I think perhaps its that expectations my not have been met, whatever those were.

--What if Jesus was a time traveler?

reply

This was not a remake of Chinatown. Just 'cause it made a couple not-too-subtle allusions to a noir masterpiece does not mean this is a remake of that film in highschool dress. Apart from an investigation of a mystery and a basic 3 Act structure, the plotlines are completely different and the stakes worlds apart, and while Chinatown kept one on the edge of his seat, this whole affair was rather ho-hum and melodramatic.

I didn't "hate" the movie. The writers certainly have a gift for dialogue, but some of the plotting was just too absurd (paint-ball gun school schooting; "locked-up" in detention; principal physically threatening students). Perhaps they just didn't set the right tone. Would be difficult with this material; it's just too farcical, yet the film wasn't going for out and out laughs - it was more a dramedy than a comedy. That's why people didn't buy the silly stuff, I think.

...................
It's a movie, people! It's not, nor is it meant to be, real life!

reply

Precisely. How can I take the opinions seriously when not one person here mentions the obvious. Have you people seen Chinatown? For christ sakes, the last line in this film is lifted right from the last friggin line in Chinatown.

Hey, it's been a long time since I've seen Chinatown, but the one thing in the movie that jumped out at me and shouted "Chinatown!" was when the guy coughs while he rips the page out of the book in the study hall.

But let's be perfectly honest. The audience this film is targeted to probably never even heard of Chinatown, the same way a lot of the people who saw Disturbia never heard of or saw Rear Window before.

http://stuffblackpeopledig.wordpress.com/

reply

Stupid movie I agree. Thank god for Redbox. I saw it for only $1

reply