MovieChat Forums > Redbelt (2008) Discussion > some major suspension of disbelief neede...

some major suspension of disbelief needed at the end


Look, I'm not interested in the raging debate here between the haters and the lovers. Never has a film seemed to have split people down the middle so much.

I'm gonna sit on the fence however. I enjoyed the earlier half of the film, and Ejiofor is always the best thing in anything he's in. For me, the film lost the plot at the end, and in particular the score near the end was horrible, so kitch.




BUUUUUT what I really wanted to say was that the fact that the fight at the end even occured was, unfortunately for the film, laughable. At a major event such as this there's a heck of a lot of security. The only job these people have is to make sure everything runs smoothly, and no fights break out outside of the ring.

And holy handbaskets, no-one can refute that if some nobody (or anybody for that matter) started a fight with the star of the show, he's gonna have about 10 guys leap on top of him and drag him away immmmmediately. The dudes ending the night in a jail cell, not as a hero honoured by the Japanese.

The bit that summed it all up was when Randy Couture looks over and points the fight out, and then everyone starts watching, like they knew that this battle had a particular special significance. Well unless they're psychic, Randy and anyone else working at the event (who wasn't in on the fix) wouldn't have a clue as to why it was going on and would be shouting for security to intervene. And at that point...we see security holding back civilians so that the fight can continue! I couldn't help but laugh, and cry- "How is this happening?!" at the screen.



I really hope I don't have someone respond to this with "It's just a movie, dude." Because the whole "It doesn't have to be realistic" argument frustrates me when the film is based in reality. Real people should act how real people act, and they definitely shouldn't act based on information that they don't have.

reply

It's just a movie, man...but at least we agree that Ejiofor is always a pleasure to watch on the big screen. I'd like to see him do a lot more.

reply

Most movies require a certain amount of suspension of disbelief. But then, there are times that this real life we lead requires the same suspension of disbelief. I am being mildly humorous making that statement.

Life, every now and then, behaves as though it had seen too many bad movies

reply

[deleted]

The star of the show challenged HIM after Mike made it clear he was going to expose the fight as being fixed. He also fought off 3-4 guys to get near him. Maybe the other security dudes didn't want their asses kicked. You sort of get the impression earlier the fight is being run on a shoestring budget because of the lack of interest.

Having said that, the entire ending is a bit unrealistic but I think the underlying message at the VERY END was worth getting across. People don't make films about mundane events that have routine outcomes. There is something almost supernatural about everyone understanding the significance of what was happening but I thought that was pretty cool actually.

reply