MovieChat Forums > Live Earth (2007) Discussion > Know who should've played

Know who should've played


The Tragically Hip

Sens Rule

reply

Bump

Sens Rule

reply

Personally, I wanted Green Day to play. They played Live 8 and were (are) awesome.

reply

well greenday's doing another charity thing

reply

Dave Gilmour, Paul Rodgers, Aerosmith, Kiss, ACDC - bands that didnt play at live aid or 8

reply

Dave Gilmour played guitar for Brian Ferry at Live Aid. Waters asked if Gilmour was interested in reforming Floyd for Live Earth. Gilmour said "no".

Paul Rogers is a minor rock singer who used to be in moderatly successfull (30 years ago) rock band Free and then somehow got the gig singing for Queen (why?Why?WHY?WHY!!!???) despite being totaly unsuitable to fill Freddie's shoes (but who could come near? George Michael maybe, or Robert Plant, possibly...). That's why he wasn't asked.

Aerosmith don't sell very many records any more. Oh, and they suck. That's why they weren't asked.

Kiss. See Aerosmith above...

AC/DC famously turned down a request to play at Live Aid and then did the same for it's sister Oz For Africa concert. As such it's doubtfull they were asked to play Live 8 or Live Earth.




"I think you're a load of old crap too, Mr Mulligan."

reply

ohh gee, i didnt know about acdc, i didnt know about dave gilmour, and im not fussed with you implying that aerosmith and paul rodgers suck but for *beep* sake were do u get off sayin Kiss suck?! they are one of the best bands in the world as well as Queen, Led Zeppelin and Bon Jovi. im interested wat bands are u into? please do not say anything thats out today, because todays music is not music at all, usually you play instruments yourself in a band of a few people, not have them made through a computer.

(to hallogallo... that last shot was at u in general, it was just my hate of hip hop and dance music and other *beep* of today)

reply

Actualy Queen were quite good at the 46664 Concert a couple of weeks back and despite forgeting the lyrics on "One Vision" (it's OK Paul only around 300,000,000 TV/internet viewers saw it LOL) Paul hardly disgraced himself. Still, he was no Freddie...

I'm sorry but I really don't "get" Kiss. I find their music trite and uniteresting. I like good metal (Motorhead, Iron Maiden, Metallica up until the "black album", Black Sabbath, Guns 'n' Roses, Megadeth, Exodus...) and good hard rock (Slade, Big Country, Bon Jovi (well albums 3 and 4, have never heard any others by them), Def Leppard...) but Kiss for me just don't fall into either catagory.

Their live shows really don't look too inspired either. Example:

Back in the early 90's before I got a lot more choosey about what gigs I attended I saw 3 arena gigs with initial impressive stage sets, these being ZZ Top (a scrap yard with complete with cranes and car crusher), Billy Idol ("apocalyptic landscape" complete with massive moving staue of Billy) and AC/DC (masses of ramps for Angus to run around and 16 working cannons), but once the shows got underway nothing particularly interesting happened, a crane might move, smoke may below from a chimney, the statue's arm may move and point at the audience, the canons go off at set points in the set but so what? The rest of the time we were stuck watching 2cm high (if we were lucky enough to be close-ish to the stage) people moving around occasionaly. They did't even have video screens at 2 of them, and at the one they did all they ever showed was 3 beardy blokes standing around playing their instruments. Pretty underwhelming concert experiences in all 3 cases.

I have a feeling Kiss' shows would be like that for me. Gene Simmons (or is it one of the others) spits blood, some things onstage explode sometimes, the brumkit lifts up on a hydrolic ramp, etc. Concidering that I don't like the music I have a feeling it'd all be just a big bore for me.

I don't know if your American so I don't know if this argument counts but here goes. I think there is also a cultural thing, that Brits tend not to "get" Kiss, but then again Yanks don't "get" Status Quo. Brits don't "get" Alicia Keys, Yanks don't get Take That. Swings and roundabouts...

For what it's worth I'm into all sorts of music. At the momment (ie the last couple of days) I've listened to a lot of David Bowie (mostly "Young Americans", "Lodger", "Station to Station" and "Low" but other stuff as well), Tiny Tim, just discovered Robin Gibb's 80's solo LPs, probably lots of other things too. In general I like psychedelic music (in it's broadest sense, though I very much tend to go for the weirder stuff (Basil Kirchin's "Quantum" LP, "Electrical Storm" by the White Noise...)), jazz (mostly free jazz), lots of stuff.

I disagree completly with what you say about bands/computers. I've used this argument before in that if you listen to the intro, first verse and first chorus of "Biology" by Girls Aloud you'll hear more inspiration and imagination than say Razorlight, the Fratellies and the Editors (or whatever indie band the quality press are pushing this week) will ever manage in their entire combined careers. Listen to "the Richard D. James" EP by the Aphex Twin and you'll hear more ideas than if you listened to 200 of the latest CDs by the latest underground death metal bands.







"I think you're a load of old crap too, Mr Mulligan."

reply

lol, well i supose u gotta point with the fact u don't get kiss, im Australian and i love all types of music except hip hop and dance/techno, i find it boring coz its just the same thing repeated over and over again and if played loud it just a headache, also coz half the time with rapping ya cant hear wat the hell their saying.
I say, if ya can play it live on a drum kit, then its ok on a computer, but if they take a beat and distort it and add like flange effects on it then thats just crap.
Also with ur point on death metal being less inspiring thats just coz all there songs are just playing in Em, and emo bands have the same problems, just generic chords with whingey lyrics over the top, but everynow and again ya get a few good songs (blink 182 and Greenday's earlier stuff.)

thats good ur gettin back into the older stuff, like Bowie and Robin Gibb, ive just recently gotten back into Pink Floyd again which i took a small break from just to see wat else i missed in the 70's coz im only 18.

ohh well, i guess everyones into different music and its just opinions.

reply