MovieChat Forums > Un conte de Noël (2008) Discussion > Talking cubes in some desolate French to...

Talking cubes in some desolate French town


Plot: The Vuillard family is no stranger to physical/mental illness, loss, and banishment. So, basically, they're pretty much all *beep* crazy. But when the matriarch (Catherine Deneuve) becomes in need of a transplant, due to a rare cancer, the whole family is forced to come together, emotional baggage and all, just in time for Christmas. Premise for a sad mad entertaining ride.
Running time: 153 minutes.

Judging by the poster, and the popularity of this film, I expected a multi-faceted lovely visit with the Vuillards, along with a Christmas dinner of cynical & flawed characters, carried forth by clever dialogue. You know, like 99.9% of most French films. Instead, I got 126 minutes of rubik cube people talking. Pugnacious rhetoric. Like, all the time.

The talking cube people monologued to a level, the barometer of talk-measure exploded. Each character was so deeply entrenched in their respective dysfunctionality, this ship of a movie sank to the depths of awfulness. Talking dice. They all were like talking dice. Bumping into each other and hardly acknowledging each other. Even in the same room together, they never actually spoke to each other. And if they did, I did not know what the hell they were talking about. Relatability failed.

The disjointed assembly of characters lacked connections to each other and to us, the audience. Not a timid spark flew between them. Engine flooded. Turkey dead. Flatliner all the way.

To be fair, seeing all these wonderful actors sludge through the drudgery is definitely preferable to enduring a Hollywood mirror image with candidates like Jennifer Aniston or Mathew McConnaughy.

reply

"The talking cube people monologued to a level, the barometer of talk-measure exploded. Each character was so deeply entrenched in their respective dysfunctionality, this ship of a movie sank to the depths of awfulness. Talking dice. They all were like talking dice. Bumping into each other and hardly acknowledging each other. Even in the same room together, they never actually spoke to each other. And if they did, I did not know what the hell they were talking about. Relatability failed. "

I don't think you watched the whole thing if this is your assessment.

reply