MovieChat Forums > Battlestar Galactica: Razor (2007) Discussion > Razor Plothole or hint? Starbuck's Palm...

Razor Plothole or hint? Starbuck's Palm reading.

posted 17 years ago by anprice2
5 replies | jump to latest

Okay, I watched Razor last night and near the end Starbuck remarks about how she has a destiny and how her "palm-reading" was proof to that effect. Apollo just laughs in response.

Please, correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't her palm reading happen on New Caprica, which would be months after all the events in Razor are taking place?

Now, if I'm right, the question is: was this a minor oversight by the writers or an intentional hint as to Starbuck's role/knowledge of things to come?

[–] Bernnard_Black 17 years ago

I assume she was referring to the discussion with the "captured" Leoben, when he told her about having a destiny. This was way before Razor, so it isn't a plot hole.

[–] edo3050-1 16 years ago

It is not a assumption, Leoben did talk to Starbuck about her destiny when he was being held on the Galactica.

[–] peach_flan 16 years ago

Yes he did.

[–] fit_ov_fury 16 years ago

I think you are looking for things that aren't there to fit your theory rather than fitting your theory round the evidence.

[–] jinpa5 16 years ago

Starbuck says to Lee that a "cylon palm-reader" told her she had a destiny to fulfill, so Lee would have to see her until the end: it was Leoben she was referring to, as the others here wrote.