MovieChat Forums > Battlestar Galactica: Razor (2007) Discussion > Clue to the final cylon? (SPOILERS)

Clue to the final cylon? (SPOILERS)


Did anyone else notice that the weird static sound Kendra hears when she listens to the radio is exactly the same sound that they played when the last four cylons were "coming out"? I know there was no music this time, but isn't it strange that they would use that same sound again? Am I right that these are the only two episodes in which we have ever heard it?

So I'm wondering if it's a clue that Kendra is the final cylon. That would be kind of cool. I liked her character and would like to see her come back. Also, it would keep any of the other more obvious candidates from turning out to by a cylon.

reply

Well... if you think about it, none of the final four appear in this episode, so maybe that's a clue that the final cylon didn't either?

"El tiempo está dando vueltas en redondo."

reply

Uh, Colonel Tigh did appear in Razor, sorry.


Kara Thrace will lead the human race to its end. She is the herald of the apocalypse. The harbinger of death. They must not follow her.

reply

I was thinking that too. when she talks to the hybrid it said "i've been waiting for you" which made me think that she may be the final of the five

reply

im not convinced that they are cylons. everyone that heard the music was down on the planet..anyone else thinking some sort of experiments or implants done on them.

reply

kara thrace also states that she used to be obsessed with listening to the radio

reply

No.
When you stop and think about it, if you think you are human, you act like a human. When you think you are a cylon, you act like a cylon. Now actions are what define a person, so if I acted a certain way because I thought I was a cylon, does that make me a cylon? (I say yes, it does.)

So, my main point is, if they think they are cylons, then they are cylons.

Also, there is the fun in watching the story that is actually told to us, rather than doubting and denying everything. And I am not even sure why you can't accept that these characters can be cylons, we have not seen s4 yet. What happens if they perfectly explain how it all happened?
---
BtVS/other files, check profile.

reply

That's not exactly accurate. Baltar thought he was a cylon, but that didn't make him one - Boomer the opposite. One is either a Model of a Cylon or not, regardless of his thoughts. But it's an interesting point though.

reply

I think the final human Cylon is whoever is the leader of the cylons.

reply

What I really want to know is why did he tell her about Kara? Was it for the sake of the audience, was he hoping she'd tell someone else before she nuked the ship or is she the final Cylon and this was just necessary information to protect humanity from doom.

Anyway, it's Lee Adama. He's the final Cylon, just you wait. He didn't hear the music because he's the one responsible for it. Don't ask me to explain. All will be revealed in episode 10 of season 4. And then we have a long-ass wait for the conclusion.

reply

So that makes Apollo half cylon? Buhahaha

reply

"{All will be revealed in episode 10 of season 4.}"
I had heard there would be a full 20 episodes in season 4. But your right that it'll be a long wait, april 08 or later cause of the writers guild strike.

reply

Everyone is a Cylon!! Could that be possible??

reply

That's what i thought. Then again, I also thought Bill, Roslin, Dee and Kara were Cylons. But oh well. We'll find out soon enough.

reply

small experimental thought:
in crossroads, when the final 4 find out they're cylons, I remember to have seen Lee tumbling & a bit shaken while all the pilots are running - perhaps he got his dose of static as well, but somehow he wasn't that affected as the other 4 were - this might also apply to the theory that he's a half cylon, which could explain that the issues the others went through didn't affect him that much...
In contrast to the others, he was never confronted with the final truth which didn't leave him questioning himself and therefore was able to focus on his own goal...

reply

I'm confused.....isn't the hybrid in the film (the old guy in the tub) the final cylon? Who are the other cylons then? I thought that one of them was the nutty lady in the tub....am I wrong?

reply

He's a hybrid. An evolutionary dead-end. He is not the fifth Cylon.

The last episode of S03 and BSG: Razor are trying to elude that Starbuck that is the 5th Cylon.

...but that seems to obvious.

reply

"all this has happened before.. and it will happen again!"

So, the hybrid was waiting and knew that she would turn up.

reply

How do we know that the Hybrid isnt lieing about starbuck?

reply

How do we know that the Hybrid isnt lieing about starbuck?

We don't. I think he/it was lying and pulling a Leoben on Shaw. Plus she was practically half dead on her feet at the time and not thinking straight. For what purpose would the Hybrid be doing the Colonials a favor? They were there to kill him.

reply

The Cylons are/were trying to extinguish humanity. The original Hybrid and his guardian fleet are a rogue element within the greater Cylon society, or whatever you want to call it.

We don't know that the Hybrid and his Guardians have a similar agenda to the other Cylons. He very well could have been trying to help humanity, or even help the Cylons from walking down a path that they couldn't return from in destroying the human race, or protecting them from whatever revelations there were on the way to Earth.

Also, if Starbuck is the final Cylon, 'they must not follow her' may be in reference that the Cylons must not follow Starbuck, not that the Colonials must not.

Overall, we don't know anything about the Hybrid, his goals, his insight, etc. We will have to wait and see, but his message was much more vague than it might seem on the surface.

For that matter, even if he was 'pulling a Leobon' we don't know for sure that Leobon was actually playing mind games. He could be an Oracle, and have all of the insight that he claims.

reply

I don't see how Lee can be the last cylon, for me he would seem the least likely, with the admiral being his dad and all.

reply

I agree. The human-looking cylons are not born as children and then grow and mature physically as Lee did (we presume), rather they are "born" as adult clones of the same model, and we can assume they do not age since each of the clones we have seen appear to be the same age. So it would be difficult for either Adama to be a cylon, since we saw the Admiral as a young man in Razor, and assume Lee grew up as a child under his father. For that matter, it would be difficult for Tigh to be a cylon too, since one assumes that he also aged and Bill having known him for a long time probably knew him as a young man. Still, anything is possible with the so-called final five since they were said by Ron Moore to be "different" cylon models.

reply

I seem to remember a statement by the producers that Kara isn't a cylon and that the final fifth is yet to be revealed, this was released just after the season 3 finale. I don't have a link but I imagine it shouldn't be hard to find if you look well.

reply

[deleted]

I don't see why making Kendra the final cylon would be logical. She was brand new to the show, and doesn't have any kind of obvious "destiny" like Starbuck, Baltar or Roslin. I think those 3 are the only real candidates, and Roslin is a stretch because the blood of Hera is what cured her cancer.

Baltar and Kara have the exact same kind of mysterious quality around them: Baltar being carried under the wing of the cylons, Kara having the "destiny". They are both part of God's plan, so we would believe, and I think the only logical conclusion is that the final cylon is one of these two. Most logically Kara - how else could she have blown up and then come back?

Then again, on Caprica when the Cylons attacked, an atomic bomb went off that by all rights should have killed Baltar. Five minutes later we see him catching a ride on a raptor to Galactica with Sharon. So, did he really survive, or was the Gaius at the raptor a clone and a cylon?

reply

I have wondered if the final five cylons are in fact between the hybrid in Razor and the ones we have seen through out BSG. They could be after the hybrid in Razor but another failure since they don't seem to be present in the cylon fleet.

It could have taken the cylons years to get the human form right.

reply

One thing that interested me: The hybrid called her a herald; in Greek mythology Zeus' herald (Hermes) is a trickster (fits Starbuck's personality), escorts the dead to the underworld (fits the hybrids warning of her leading humans to doom), and he is often identified by his winged sandals and staff (think about Starbuck's tattoo).

That being said, I would really love Starbuck not to by the final cylon. I would love to see the 5th cylon issue unresolved until the 11th hour and have Kendra return.

reply

[deleted]

Starbuck and her Viper exploded in "Malstorm" episode of Season three. Hence, if she was human then there is no coming back from that incident; but since Cylon do come back via resurection then starbuck is the fifth and final cylon.

reply

Ron Moore has already SEVERAL times around said that Kara is not the final cylon. We don't know what she is, but somehow she resurrected as she really did die.

reply

By that logic, Dualla could be the last Cylon. and she'd be a better candidate plotwise, too, since it would hit harder to have Lee's wife be the one.

Of course, the hardest blow of all would be if Ellen Tigh were the one, and if she came back and tried to seduce Saul to the dark side, as it were.

reply

I'm in the camp that believes starbuck is the 5th tho I am fully open to the idea that it is in fact someone else. I've heard theories and argument stating everyone from Adama to the president is the 5th but for me Kara is the only one that makes sense at this point especially with the prototype hybrid saying that she would the herald of humanities destruction or however he put it. Of course all the evidence pointing to her could turn out to be the writers trying to direct attention in one direction so they can pull out someone completely different in the end. I guess we'll just have to wait and see

reply

Yeah I agree. I really want to see how the writers try to explain how Kara somehow returned from the dead. Her ship was blown to peaces, and even if she ejected out of the Viper, she would have been ripped to shreds by the planet's gravitational force.

reply

All of this has happened before and will again.


It is my theory, that this is true, that they are stuck in some kind of loop, where man creates cyclon and cyclon destroys nearly all of man, man creates cyclon etc.

Even in this cycle there is purpose, wouldn't the harbinger of doom, herald of death be apt names for one who could end that cycle.

reply

I'd like to see a logical argument of how Kara CAN'T be a cylon? I thought it was a given that she is, we saw her die!

reply


Not too much about the 5th Cylon, but I thought that the tub Cylon was actually the original series' Baltar, that defected to the Cylons. In that case, it explains why the tub Cylon was surrounded by old style Raiders and Centurions, why it's a "hybrid" and why it jolly-well knows whether or not Starbuck will destory humanity rather than save it. Tub-Baltar's been down the road before; humanity leaves Earth to colonize. Colonies build Cylons, Cylons revolt, Cylons destroy colonies, humans leave to find Earth, wash, rinse, repeat. That's why Tub-Baltar keeps saying "This has happened before and will happen again." or whatever the precise quote was.

reply

The whole "it's all happened before and will happen again" better not be as literal as it sounds. I would appreciate it if the current situation reflected the original colonies experience with the gods or something along that vein. But, to say that it's a continuous cycle between human and cylon dilutes this show down to nothing more than the third Matrix movie.

Hopefully Kara isn't the 5th cylon - perhaps she was rescued by a "final five" cylon contingent. If that is so that would sadly rule out Kendra as the 5th one. Unless Starbuck escaped...

reply

The idea that the cylon's destruction of humanity mirrors that of an ancient human rebellion against the Greek gods on Earth has plausibility within the context of BSG. The show is heavily based in Greek mythology and its cycle of children rebelling against parents, from Old gods to Titans to Olympic gods to humans to cylons, or "humanity's children" as they have been called. Twelve human colonies destoyed by twelve cylon models also mirrors the twelve titans defeated by the twelve Olympic gods...each generation rebelled and defeated the preceding one. We'll see this season if humanity manages to break the cycle and destroy its children.

reply


"but I thought that the tub Cylon was actually the original series' Baltar"

The original series in not part of continuity for the current. Right? Because if it is, then I am really effing confused.


He was killed by the C.I.A for selling smack... to Nazis...

reply

The actor who played the origional Baltar died a few years ago.

reply

The actor who played the origional Baltar died a few years ago.


7 Years actually

-- COOOBRAAAA! --

reply

I think the final cylon is lee. When adama dipped his hand into that tub, he probably transferred a bit of his dna into it. And if everything has already happened...

reply

Lee Doesn't fit the mold of Human Cylon models.


A) HE HAS PARENTS THAT ARE ALIVE. Every other cylon model had no immiediate family.

B) He wasn't left on new caprica. The so called "Final four" all were left on new caprica.

The Cylon's don't seem to REPLACE people...they seem to create them.

reply

Also, Adama was wearing a pressurized flight suit with gloves on. No way the tub goo had any skin contact. That thing is sealed tight enough for emergency space evacs.

reply

I had to re-read this to relize you were not referring to John Colicos (the guy who played Baltar in the original). Once I got it--GREAT IDEA.

reply

Sounds a little too much like Mayan prophecy to me.

reply

Oh the 5th Cylon is going to be played by Dirk Benedict.

reply

[deleted]

I caught this also, very interesting as I completely missed it my first time around. I am fairly certain Kendra is the 5th of the final five. The static she heard while switching stations was exactly the same, and if you look carefully she has a very subtle and slight look of confusion on her face while it plays.

Why else would they have put the fact that she listens to the radio in the story? It really had no real point and they could easily have done without it, so I think it was a huge clue.

I'll be glad to see her back. She's an interesting character. I really cannot wait for season 4. It better be worth the one year wait.

reply

I'd like to think it may be Cain, but I doubt it's her or Kendra. The Hybrid said that four of the Five would soon become aware of who they are, while the Fifth lies in shadow, seeking redemption. This could apply to Kendra or Cain (or several others, for that matter). I know Cain had memories of her childhood, but so do the rest of the "sleepers". The problem with both Kendra and Cain, though, is that I'm thinking there was only one of each of the first Five. I could just be pulling that out of the air, and I'm having trouble finding which episode I heard that in (if I heard it at all). If that's the case, though, it would be ridiculous for it to be either of them, because they were both introduced and then killed off very quickly, taking the Fifth out of the picture already.

reply

Amazing how little this thread has focused on what the hybrid actually said. It was pretty clearly not random.

At last they've come for me.

I feel their lives, their destinies spilling out before me. The denial of the one true path, played out on a world not their own, will end soon enough.


Earth?

Soon there will be four, glorious in awakening. Struggling with the knowledge of their true selves. The pain of revelation bringing new clarity. And in the midst of confusion, he will find her, enemies brought together by impossible longing, enemies now joined as one.

Obviously the four we saw revealed at the end of last season, although I don't think I would ever refer to either Tyrol or Tigh as "glorious." Who are the "he" and "her" though? My guess is Starbuck and Leoban.

The way forward, at once unthinkable, yet inevitable.

And the Fifth, still in shadow, will claw toward the light, hungering for redemption that will only come in the howl of terrible suffering.


The Hybrid's question to Kendra feeds right into this. If she is the final model (which would be what's known in writer's circles as a "cheat"), but thinks she is human, then her redemption is for the sins she committed on Pegasus, and the terrible suffering comes with the revelation of her true nature.

I can see them all.

The seven, now six, self-described machines who believe themselves without sin. But in time, it is sin that will consume them.

They will know enmity, bitterness, the wrenching agony of the one splintering into the many.

And then they will join the promised land, gathered on the wings of an angel.


Obviously our skinjob Cylon buddies, who we saw descend into almost constant bickering on New Caprica. But who do we know who has a tattoo of wings? *screws up face, Church-Lady style* Could it be......Starbuck?

Not an end...but a beginning

Because Ron Moore is finally going to start working on the Caprica prequel series he promised us years ago?

As far as the "warning" the Hybrid gives Kendra.

Kara Thrace will lead the human race to its end. She is the herald of the apocalypse. The harbinger of death. They must not follow her.


The "end" is not necessarily a bad thing, if it's something along the lines of "they end up on Earth" As for the rest of it, The Leoban model, we've been told, believes the literal word of the Hybrids. We've seen that the Leobans are slippery, semantic tricksters, and I would not be surprised if the Hybrids can be as well. The apocalypse and death might actually be for the Cylons, and Starbuck's resurrection (not in the Cylon sense) is was harbinges (is that a word? it is now.) the Cylon demise.

reply

Hmmm . . . if you consider the final three seconds of the S3 finale, it's clear that Starbuck was planning on leading *everybody,* humans and Cylons alike, to Earth. The "they" who must not follow her could easily be the Cylons, not the humans.

reply

hmmm, one thing that strikes me is that "Seven, now six" line. That suggests the seven known Cylons and D'anna's fall... but that doesn't happen for about a year from Razor's time.

reply

"All of this has happend before, All of this will happen again, again, again," It is clear the hybrid has the memories of all the failed attempts to create hybrids. Hybrids were first used to navigate the cylons ships according to the cylon Boomer. If you think about the human brian, it runs on electrical impluses or waves to be simplistic. A cellphone works the same way where a wireless signal spreads across the entire planet until the right cellphone is located and the cellphone starts ringing. Kendra Shaw was sending so much emotional memories that the hybrid detected these memories. Hence, he knew who she was as well the location of all of his 12 cylon children.

reply

"If you think about the human brian, it runs on electrical impluses or waves to be simplistic."

I'm Brian and so's my wife.


reply

I think it's fairly obvious that the fifth will be Kendra.

Why?

1) As pointed out elsewhere in this thread, Kendra hears the static. So far, the only ones who've heard the static are the Final Five.

2) Again, as pointed out elsewhere in this thread, the Final Five all have no immediate living relatives -- Kendra's mother was mentioned as having died of cancer.

3) Kendra has many of the traits we've expected from the human-form Cylons-- extra resiliency, good familiarity with computers, etc.

4) The comments from the old hybrid fit perfectly -- that she is in the shadow, struggling for redemption. (In this sense, double meaning-- first that she was responsible for the deaths on the Scylla, and second that she killed the old hybrid.) It is possible that the Final Five are NOT capable of resurrection in the same way the other seven are-- they are more "individual"--, and this is why we have not seen multiple copies of any of them -- so when she "died" on the Guardian's basestar, she is waiting to be resurrected, and that's why we haven't seen her since. This also fits with Three's trying to kill herself to see the fifth Cylon, who is waiting "in the dark", in the space between death and rebirth. Remember Three's comment when she saw who the fifth was -- "You... forgive me... I had no idea." (referring to Kendra's "death" on the basestar, which presumably everybody knew about after the fact)

5) The comments that the old hybrid make to Kendra with regard to Starbuck-- since the hybrid knows that she is the fifth, he is communicating important information to her... namely that Starbuck must not be allowed to take the humans to Earth. The "end" that he is referring to is not a bad end, but a good end (for the humans, that is!). The apocalypse he mentions is the apocalypse for the Cylons, not for the humans. His statement is ambiguous in that way.

That being said, it's just bad form in writing to introduce a character like this toward the end of the series and make them a central plot figure ... smacks of deus ex machina...

reply

2) Again, as pointed out elsewhere in this thread, the Final Five all have no immediate living relatives -- Kendra's mother was mentioned as having died of cancer.

In the extended DVD version, we find out that Kendra's mother was a well known politician on Caprica, Quorum delegate Marta Shaw. (That's why Cain says she already knows Kendra's mother was dead, "I read the papers.") So we have undeniable proof that her mother was real.


better sorry than safe

reply

Undeniable proof that her mother was real, yes, but that wasn't my point. We have no proof that Tyrol's parents weren't real, and yet he is apparently one of the Final Five.

reply

Kendra Shaw is not the final cylon since she was not on New Caprica nor did she appear in episode "Downloaded" of season 2. Producer Ron Moore stated on the DVD version of Season 2.5 that "Downloaded" was his favorite of the series. I suspect he said that because all five and final cylons made an appearance in the episode. Colonel Tigh, Tyrol, Tory, Anders, and the fifth cylon appeared in this episode. Since Starbuck nor Kendra Shaw appeared in "Download" they are elimanted as suspects. However, Maya, who would raise Baby Hera, is a clear front runner for the fifth cylon. However, since the next two episodes Laydown your burden" part one and two introduced the cylon Brother Cavil who is quite old for a cylon. The age factor would bring to suspect the good Galactica doctor Cottle since he is old. I believe the 12 cylon models plan was to conceive babies on their own but they failed, hence, they needed a human to achieve a hybrid baby as Tyrol and Boomer have achieved on their own. Hence, the final five cylons would be considered rebels and believe that humans and cylons should live as one as the the Hybrid of the film Razor says should happen. Hence Leoben and Starbuck are enemies joined as one through the birth of a child of their own in season four.

reply

Ron Moore never said that all 5 Cylons appeared in "Downloaded". Where did you get that? I suspect he said it was his favourite episode because it is an awesome episode. It's my favourite, too. (Although on the Razor DVD he named "33" and "Lay Down Your Burdens II", not "Downloaded".)

But RDM did say that the final Cylon is someone they had thoughts about making a Cylon since season 1, and that there are already clues in the series... he said that before Razor. Therefore the final one must be someone who has already been a part of the series.

better sorry than safe

reply

I heard the podcast commentary for the episode "Downloaded" which can be found on the Season 2.5 DVD release and he clearly stated that the episode was his favorite. Bear in mind, Razor was not made yet nor requested by the studio heads before "Downloaded" was first broadcast. Personally, the DVD verison of Razor is much better than the broadcast verison so the DVD does give alot of clues to who could be the fifth and final cylon. But you can not deny the fact that "Downloaded" mainly revolved on the life of a cylon and the birth of the baby Hera. As for the four cyclons we do know: Colonel Tigh made a brief appearance during the President's debate of Hera's future in the fleet. Tyrol made his brief appearance when the ashes of Hera were spread in the void of space by Helo in the Galactica Raptor. Tory made her second series appearance when she handed Doc Cottle the list of possible candidates who would take care of Baby Hera. As for Anders well he was on Caprica and was taunted by Cylon D'Anna to shoot her with his own weapon with D'Anna taunting Caprica Boomer as a human sympathizer. Galactica Boomer knew Brother Calie was a cylon and didn't tell anyone as she was mad about losing her baby Hera during "Downloaded". Outside of learning more about the cylons in "Downloaded" Doc Cottle took alot of screen time over the rest of the regulars on the show. But the fifth cyclon is hiding in the shadow if you by the DVD verison of Razor. The only other charcter in "Downloaded to make a brief appearance is Maya, who took care of Baby Hera. In quite obivious that Maya or Doc Cottle are the only true candidites for the fifth cylon. One was the selective and the other the selector in regards to the future of baby Hera.

reply

And what does that have to do with anything? Did he say in the podcast that all final five Cylons appeared in "Downloaded"? I don't think so. And that's what we're debating, not whether it's his favourite episode.


better sorry than safe

reply

Ron Moore has stated that there has been clues throughout the series. Well, the entire episode "Downloaded is infested with clues. The purpose of this thread is to show who is the fifth cylon. All the seven cylons that were known before the start of season three truely hate the human race. Eventhough, Hero Cylon Caprica Six and Caprica Boomer wanted to change the human/cylon relationship; the episode Rapture from Season three Caprica Boomer has had a change of heart. In Rapture, Caprica Boomer wanted to kill baby Hera before Caprica six and Athena took baby Hera back to the fleet. Back to Downloaded of season 2, its is a fact that Tyrol, Tory, Tigh, and Anders made an appearance. Roslin did not make the list but more to the point that Tory made the list herself. The list of candidates who would take care of Hera. Doc Cottle made the final judgement call so hence that makes him a good 5th cylon. Doc Cottle was at the beginning of the series so there you go. Both Tory and Andars were not at the beginning but there were chosen by Ron Moore to be cylons. As for a person not appearing at the start of the series, Maya is a perfect candidate as she is presumed dead but can appear again as the fifth cylon. In the end, there are no other candidates from "Doenloaded" who were hiding in the shadow (i.e supporting roles) and who had been stranded on New Caprica when the cylons arrived and the fleet left.

reply

Um... so? Whoever said that all of the final five appear in the episode 'Downloaded'? No one? So your speculation (and it is just speculation) is senseless.

Also, we don't know that being stranded on New Caprica has anything to do with being one of the final five. I do wish people would stop broadcasting thier speculative theories as disclosed facts and claiming it's "obvious". The only thing that's obvious is that the identity of the fifth cylon isn't obvious at all.

"That sound you hear, is stunned silence."

reply

Good fraking points... well said. I too believe that the Hybrid's message should not be taken lightly. I also think that his point of view (as said in later posts) should also not be held lightly. Is Starbuck the harbinger of death for humans??? ...or Cylons??? Or both???

I really hate not knowing what is coming next, but I think they have done a great job with this one. I am usually good at figuring out plots, but with this... no clue! I guess we have to wait... and I hate waiting.

So keep throwing stuff out there, and I'll chime in when I have to. But as I said, nice quoting the Hybrid... there is just a lot to digest from all he/it said. And too many possibilities to comprehend.

OK, enough typing. I have to get back to watching the entire 2.0 season... again... just in case I missed something. And yes... 2.5 is next...

reply

SPOILER POST.

Just watched Razor abit earlier.

"And the fifth, still in shadow, will claw toward the light, hungering for redemption that will only come in the howl of terrible suffering"

First I just thought Baltar would be somekind of Jesus, know I'm sure he's the cylon Jesus and the fifth of the five.

I mean he's already portrayed as some sort of Jesus or atleast some very strong connection to the cylon Jesus.
He's got the hair and beard right for how Jesus is normally portrayed, and he got this habit of posing as a cross, like when he's drugged and thinks he's in water, or when he collapse on Kobol.

There's also another hybrid in s3 which says something about his mind is burning like a fire and that he is the chosen one.

He himself have said that the only way he will find redemption is if he was a cylon. He did play a major role in almost wiping out the human race.

His home was obliterated by a nuclear blast wave which no human could survive while he was in it. Number Six only survived that blast wave by being downloaded.

Right before Number Three says she's sorry to one of the five in s3, that would could possible fit Anders and maybe even Tigh(We do not know who poked out his eye). But it fits Baltar even more, considering how they treated him on New Caprica.

He has a possible angel of God to guide and protect him and there's defently a link between the final five and the five priests of the one who's name cannot be spoken.... Perhaps he's the high priest, or even the child of the one who's name cannot be spoken which fits with him being their Jesus or the step-father of Jesus, afterall he is the chosen one.

The seven did not know he is a cylon, nor did they know about Tigh, Anders, the Cheif or the President's Aid being cylons.

As for the music on the Galactica at the end of s3, he wouldn't need the music to sort of activate him or what ever happens to the four others. He's speciel, he has an angel of God with him, he is the one who is in the shadow, seeking redemption and will not be "Glorious awakened" along with the other four.

The only thing I can't make to much sense of is Caprica-Six having a Balter in her head, but then again, her virtuel Baltar could also be an angel of God trying to redeem her for her role in the attack on the Colonies, but I can't figure out why she also should have an angel helping to redeem her.

That's all I can think of for Baltar.

Since there's so much about Starbuck being a cylon, even though the ones behind the show have stated she is not a cylon I'll say this:

"Enemies brought together by impossible longing, enemies now joined as one. The way forward at once unthinkable, yet inevitable. And the fifth, still in shadow, will claw toward the light, hungering for redemption that will only come in the howl of terrible suffering. I can see them all. The seven, now six, self-described machines who believe themselves without sin, but in time, it is sin that will consume them. They will know enmity, bitterness, the wrenching agony of the one splintering into the many, and then they will join the promised land, gathered on the wings of an angel. Not an end, but a beginning".
"Kara Thrace will lead the human race to its end. She is the herald of the apocalypse, the harbinger of death. They must not follow her".

I believe she's an angel, she has a destiny, she dies and comes back as an angel, the one that will lead both humans and cylons to Earth aka the promised land where they as a unified people and race..... And she got those viper(angel?) wings.

Either that or she is a demon. On Kobol they were aided by a "minor demon", she's the one that goes back for the Arrow of Apollo and the one they must not follow.

I know there's alot of religion in this post, but in real life I'm 100% atheist.

reply

Right before Number Three says she's sorry to one of the five in s3, that would could possible fit Anders and maybe even Tigh(We do not know who poked out his eye). But it fits Baltar even more, considering how they treated him on New Caprica.

If it was Baltar, why was she so surprised? "You?! Forgive me...I had no idea!" She definitely recognized somebody she would have never expected to be a Cylon. Baltar had been telling her he wondered if he was a Cylon and asking her if he she had seen his face eversince he found out about her repeated deaths and resurrections, but she told him she didn't know because she couldn't remember their faces. So it's certainly not like the thought had never crossed her mind. He would be the last person she should have showed such a surprise.

As for Baltar surviving the blast, we've already been through that, he had as much chance of surviving it as any of those survivors who ran up to Helo and Sharon's raptor. They couldn't have all been Cylons. Many people survived Hiroshima and Nagasaki as well. Baltar's house was clearly not anywhere in the center of the nuclear explosion, watch the scene and you can see how long it takes for the nuclear shockwave to reach his house. Caprica Six was probably killed by the shattered glass and walls of the house that were tumbling down.



better sorry than safe

reply

It sems likely that it was Anders she saw and asked for forgiveness, after taunting him so on Caprica and almost killing him.

reply

I would like to pint out some facts/thoughts.

1) Why are we so sure Tyrol is the father of Callie's baby? I wouldn't be so sure with that one.
2) Characters in the dark might best fit Gaeta or Zarek. Gaeta seems in a dark spot in the CIC, helped develop the Cylon detector which he may have sabatoged, may have put the thing in the CIC, may have informed the Cylons that they found the Eye of the Jupiter thing on the Algae planet seems overly bright, and may have known all along he is the 5th dude. Again may have turned on the music. Also he was in the last episode and has been involved from the start.
3) Tom Zarek is in the dark or is a dark character. His whole persona spells cylon to me. For many subtle reasons he seems to be a great candidate.
4) Brother Cavil poked out Tigh's eye
5) If Adama remember's Tigh as a younger man he either was a youger man or Adama is a Cylon with planted memories. Although it is true he has children, are they his or are they hybrid?.....

reply

A few points worth making.

THE FINAL FOUR

Cylons are machines who became aware and sentient. They then set about changing themselves into their creators but removed a human's fundamental flaw. This flaw is longevity and is overcome by the ability to "download".

The Four, I suggest, are something similar to one of Blade Runner's replicants. By this I mean a manufactured real life human being with a shorter, one shot lifespan. An earlier and now obsolete model because it simply doesn't live long enough to be useful.

Modern Cylon models are by any definition, Gods. On the other hand, the final four are every bit as Cylon, but share the possibility of mortal death of their human counterparts.

The fear of death lives large in the human psychy. I suggest that this fear was passed on to the Cylons and they came up with a remedy.

THE CYLON GOD

This dude is certainly NOT an evolutional dead end. He is the first mechanical/biological Cylon. He is literally the Missing Link. He is the bridge between circuit bones and flesh and blood.

I make an assumption that the Cylon "God" was certainly a man made AI with access to ALL human knowledge. This is why he knows that all of this has haoppened before and will happen again. He knows everything that's ever been inputted or scanned into a computer. He can see the patterns that Human's never live long enough to see and can only learn about from history.

I think it's safe to assume this. I reckon the Cylons have "detailed files" on their shared human history, it is their history too after all.

One thing that many of you guys may not have picked up on is that Sharon is in chains when she tells the brass about the nature of the Cylon God. This should tell you that this isn't "our" Athena, it's Sharon who has been in the brig and quite recently been raped by a fat bald man from the Pegasus.

She's the Sharon who somehow miraculously saved the fleet from a fleet of raiders. Remember the Cylon virus situation? At the same time as the Cylons wanted Sharon's baby to survive they where trying to destroy the Galactica? It doesn't ring true to me. It was a deliberate set up to help her gain favour from Adama and keep her alive to complete her mission.

This Sharon is a liar. She's certainly not willing to give up her creator at this or any stage of proceedings.

"There must be some way outta here" said the Joker to the Thief.

reply

*****5) If Adama remember's Tigh as a younger man he either was a youger man or Adama is a Cylon with planted memories.*****

If it's the "Adama with planted memories' option, then why would Tigh have memories of Adama? They both remember each other so they are either both human or both cylon...

reply

At the end of Razor, only six human cylons were known by any member of the human population of the fleet or by the survivors on Caprica. Hence, the cylon hybrid says seven now six to bring this fact to light. Returning to season 1, Roslin told the fleet that Cylons were now able to look like humans. Hence, pictures of known cylon human agents would be seen by the actual humans of the fleet. After the end of season 2, nobody who watches the show suspected that Tyrol, Tigh, Anders, or the new character Tory would be announced as cylons at the end of season 3. First of all, before MP3 players and digital radios, there were analong radios which always had a static sound when someone switched the channels. Therefore, using the reasoning that a character is hearing static while playing a radio is no clue to being a cylon. However, a character appearing briefly within a episode i.e season 2 "Downloaded" is a clue. Both Tigh and Tyrol appeared briefly in "Downloaded" but they were in scenes were baby Hera was the subject matter of the scene. The same can be said about Tory who was only in her second episode in the series. Tory is the one who made the list of people who could take of Baby Hera. Anders had more screen time while he was on Caprica (eventhough much of it was in the shadows of a parking garage) for a supporting character that isn't a lead like Gaius Baltar. Gaius Baltar had a good amount of screen time but he is not the 5th cylon as the hybrid in the 3rd season called him very important. Cylons say the opposite of the truth so bringing up the fact/statement that yes a hybrid called Baltar very important is to mislead you from the truth. However, Doc Cottle had a good amount of screen time in the episode "Downloaded" for just being a supporting character i.e hiding in the shadows. For anyone who saw Razor on DVD, you also saw the 44 second sneak preview of season 4 where we hear Doc Cottle's voice saying "Do you believe in miracles" and the words stamped on the screen "DESTINY IS NOT WHAT IT SEEMS". It is clear that the Razor hybrid told his children (i.e the 7 cylon humans known by the end of season 2) that Kara Thrace would destroy the human race sometime during saeson 4. That is why the human cylon Leoben is so determine to help Kara Thrace as he thinks the prophecy is true. BUT AGAIN, cylons tell the opposite of the truth and even R.D.M is telling you this thru season 4's "44" second trailer. Now, I am 110% sure that Doc Cottle is the 5th cylon.

reply

At the end of Razor, only six human cylons were known by any member of the human population of the fleet or by the survivors on Caprica. Hence, the cylon hybrid says seven now six to bring this fact to light.

Why would the Hybrid give a frak about what the Humans knew or didn't know at that point?! He wasn't talking to Humans. He was having a monologue.

He says "Seven, now Six" because there will be only 6 models left at the point of time he is talking about (which was in the future, but to the Hybrid, this doesn't matter, Time is obviously not linear for him), because model no. 3 ("D'Anna") will have been boxed at that moment in time.


better sorry than safe

reply

I'd like to reinforce what ivana2804 said above.

At the end of Razor, only six human cylons were known by any member of the human population of the fleet or by the survivors on Caprica. Hence, the cylon hybrid says seven now six to bring this fact to light.

Um, no. The Hybrid is most likely referring to the boxing of D'Anna, which takes place over a year later. Re-read what the Hybrid says about the Seven:

The seven, now six, self-described machines who believe themselves without sin. But in time, it is sin that will consume them.

They will know enmity, bitterness, the wrenching agony of the one splintering into the many.

This is exactly what starts to happen over the course of season 3. In fact, this process started as far back as season 1. The Cylons started out united: they made decisions as a group, they all wanted the same thing, they believed they were without sin, they believed it was God's will to destroy humanity, etc. Over time and after gaining individual experiences, they began to splinter. Caprica Six and Boomer both felt sympathetic to humanity and got the other Cylons to acknowledge that committing genocide against humanity was a horrendous sin. Athena chose to side with the Colonials. Making group decisions got increasingly hard on New Caprica -- they were all divided. D'Anna started doing her own thing in her quest to see "what lies between life and death," which led to her becoming a threat and then getting boxed ("The seven, now six..."). And there are many other examples of how those two sentences have been coming true over the course of the series.

So, no. The Hybrid isn't referring to what the Colonials know. He's referring to the Cylons destroying themselves by becoming consumed by their own sins and by becoming individuals. In that scene he's speaking about the past, the future, and the present like it's all happening in the present, and to him, it probably is. "All of this has happened before, and will happen again." Whether they are literally destroyed or metaphorically destroyed (e.g., the Cylons as we know them cease to exist and become something new once they gain individuality) remains to be seen.

reply

Maybe the 'head' Six (seen by Baltar), 'head' Baltar (seen by Caprica Six), 'head' Carolanne Adama (seen by Bill) and the 'head' Leoben (seen by Starbuck) are all manifestations of the final Cylon model.

A Cylon that can hop from Cylon and Human brain alike and influence their actions, remaining in the shadows of the mind.

The new series version of Count Iblis.

Or could it just be Ramo Lampkin?

Apparently the last Cylon is not in this picture:

http://www.majordojo.com/2008/01/decoding-bsgs-last-supper.php

And Ramo has been spending a lot of time with Lee recently.

Surely he would be normally be close to him at this time?






reply

Edo your logic seems flawed. I am sorry but your "downloaded" theories make no sense to me. Why does this episode have to have the 5th cylon in it? Just because Ron said it was his favorite? Great he likes that episode good times. How can you (other than a gut feeling) derive logically that the 5th cylon is in it? Can you please attempt to answer that question for me, as I am curious and feel I am missing an important piece of information.

I think that the clue about the fifth hiding in shadow or whatever tells us that the model is indeed dead and awaiting ressurection. I do not think the term shadow is trying to tell us that it is a co star, but I think this person is dead and Xena could feel the final cylon's presense when she went through the suicide phase during the period just before being ressurected but after death.

So to me Kendra is probably the best bet, although i hope she is not. But there are loads of dead people, so who knows.

My bet is the fifth cylon has already died on the show and is awaiting ressurection.

reply

It would be great for an old cast member to return as the fifth. Perhaps Billy or Ellen. I wouldn't like to see Kendra as the fifth, it would feel like such a cheat, although it is a shame that she died. I was hoping at the end of razor the hybrid might convince her to change her mind about nuking the ship and jump away (with the hybrid still alive)to return sometime in season 4.

"That sound you hear, is stunned silence."

reply

That is exactly what I've been saying since we learned of a final five, but so far you are the only other person I've seen suggest that. I personally think this is the right theory.


Also to support this is that at one time a "Six" shows up on Galactica to tell everyone about how Giaus leaked the info to the Cylons about the Defense plans, and then she just vanished into thin air without anyone knowing where she went. If she was just in their minds that explains how she vanished.

reply

Maybe Battlestar Galactica ItSELF is the final Cylon.

reply

"Maybe Battlestar Galactica ItSELF is the final Cylon."

Transformer?

I would liie to see all the cast member who have died come back as Cylons. The ones we know like Billy, Racetrack, Kendra (especially Kendra...mmmm...Kendra...), Ellen and Cain. Maybe even Chuckles.

reply

"And in the midst of confusion, he will find her, enemies brought together by impossible longing, enemies now joined as one. The way forward, at once unthinkable, yet inevitable."

I think this refers to humans and cylons breeding hybrids, and then the parent races die out.

reply